Crackers and Grape Juice

Episode 379: Christian History Almanac Weekend Edition: Meet a Real Live Methodist with Jason Micheli

·33 min·3 clips
Dan Van Voorhis invites a professional Methodist to explain why his tradition attracts both slaves and fundamentalists.
Dan Van Voorhis introduces the Weekend Edition's recurring "meet a real live" format. The format gives people room to talk about traditions listeners may not regularly worship with. He treats that distance as an invitation to curiosity. Van Voorhis places Methodism alongside Anglicanism and the Episcopal Church. The conversation notes the Methodist break from that tradition and the lack of smells and bells. The guest describes Eucharistic prayers that may be improvised or drawn from a prayer book. The discussion then turns to Methodist distinctives. The guest presents the United Methodist Church as a global body. That global structure gathers geographic, cultural, and theological differences inside one denomination. He contrasts this arrangement with churches organized as looser umbrellas. The United Methodist Church contains a wide range of positions. He describes one end as very progressive and almost unrecognizably Christian. He describes the other as severely traditional and conservative. The challenge is keeping those positions together as one family. Van Voorhis asks how that arrangement is going. The guest characterizes the path toward division as slow-moving, messy, and expensive. The presenting issue is disagreement over human sexuality. The conversation connects that disagreement to marriage and ordination. It also identifies polity as part of the dispute. The discussion points toward a larger division in the church beyond the presenting issue. Van Voorhis closes by connecting curiosity with lightheartedness. He says the show aims to present people's stories fairly, whether they feel familiar or unfamiliar to the listener. The final sign-off affirms that Jesus is good news and everything is going to be OK.

As heard by us

A clear Methodist review of the UMC's global breadth and its fault lines around sexuality, polity, marriage, and ordination.

Methodism comes through here as a tradition shaped by Anglican and Episcopal ties, flexible Eucharistic practice, and a United Methodist Church presented as one global body.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a candid Methodist-side tour of the UMC as one global body trying to hold real fault lines together.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on