Episode 5: The Trash Can Without a Lid

March 20, 2024·32 min·2 clips

A Domino's pizza man puts a gun to Ivan's head, demanding money from his cousin James days before the murders.

The case turns on ordinary clutter. A photo of the apartment kitchen becomes the pressure point: counters with debris, a white trash can, and later, the evidence sitting right where it should have been hard to miss. Matt walks through the placement of the jeans, socks, and latex gloves at rim level, then asks what Officer Younger should have seen during a search for bodies. There was no lid. These items were not buried or tucked away, which makes the silence around them hard to shrug off. Younger noted a bullet hole. So why no mention of bloody clothing and gloves sitting on top of the trash? The episode does not hand-wave the answer. First, the witness says she was one hundred percent certain the items were not there when she was inside. Then the timeline starts doing the heavy lifting. At the relevant point, Ivan and Amy are described as eight hours away in Arkansas and staying there until after the evidence is found. If the witness is right, the trash can evidence does not fit cleanly with the version where Ivan and Amy left it behind. Matt keeps the claim under pressure. The witness is the mother of a man on death row, and he says that matters. Dallas PD would not let Officer Younger discuss the wellness check. Susan Iliff/Eichenberg, the retired female officer, agreed to talk after Matt sent the photos. The episode closes by widening the circle, with Sylvia and Penny heading toward an impromptu visit with Carlos and Anthony as reasonable doubt keeps stacking up.

As heard by us

A patient evidence piece that turns one trash can into the center of the case.

The episode keeps circling a trash can without a lid, the jeans, socks, and latex gloves that may or may not have been placed there, and the fact that Ivan and Amy were already in Arkansas.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want one trash can to carry the whole burden of doubt.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cousins by Blood