Episode 3: Not His First Rodeo

March 23, 2024·33 min·2 clips

"I don't think it was his first rodeo" — the cold-open line that gives the episode its title.

The episode stays locked on the basic problem at the center of the Kitchen murders: timing. Ivan says he went over to warn James about the pizza man and left while both victims were still alive. Amy says he went there to kill them and came back with blood on him. The narration puts those versions side by side and keeps poking at the gap between them. It then moves into the next witness account, which comes from Amy's stepdad. He remembers the family arriving, the shopping trip the following day, and a ring left on the end table in the bedroom. The episode also follows the first contact from Detective Wynn after the bodies were found. Amy says Ivan told her the detective worked for them. The show treats that claim as odd and worth checking. It points out that there is no sign the homicide detective was actually working for Ivan, and it found no evidence that Ivan was tied to a mob. That leaves two possibilities on the table: Ivan made up the story to keep Amy scared, or Amy later repeated a story he had not really told. The narration stays with that uncertainty instead of smoothing it over. Later, after the story shifts to Ivan and Amy's first stop in Dallas at Tawny's apartment, Tawny gives a different reading of the case. She says Ivan did not have the chance to leave the weapon at her house because Amy was there alone all day. That shifts suspicion again and suggests a setup rather than a clean alibi. The episode ends by treating that claim as a game changer, not a conclusion. It leaves the listener with a case that still argues with itself.

As heard by us

A timeline-heavy chapter that turns strange claims into hard questions.

This episode tightens the screws on the Kitchen case by placing the competing timelines side by side and asking what actually holds up. The strongest passages return to the 11:30 p.m.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play if you want the timeline to stop lying.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cousins by Blood