CT017 - The Day We Went To War With Christmas

·41 min·3 clips

The Puritans in Massachusetts Bay Colony outlawed Christmas for over 20 years, fining celebrators five shillings.

This episode examines the historical and psychological roots of the "War on Christmas" debate. Host Ryan Nelson explores whether this perceived conflict is a modern political issue or part of a much longer cultural story. The episode opens with the text of a 1659 Massachusetts Bay Colony law that fined anyone five shillings for observing Christmas. Nelson traces the modern debate to author John Gibson's 2005 book "The War on Christmas" and its promotion on Fox News. He challenges the common claim that Christmas was a direct hijacking of pagan festivals like Saturnalia, citing the 3rd-century Calculation Hypothesis by Sextus Julius Africanus. This hypothesis used the Gospel of Luke to deduce that Jesus was conceived on March 25th and thus born on December 25th. A major historical "war" came from 17th-century English Puritans, who cancelled Christmas in 1647 and forbade any celebration. Puritan colonists in America shared this view, with Governor William Bradford of Plymouth Colony chastising men for playing games on Christmas Day. The Massachusetts Bay Colony officially outlawed Christmas celebrations from 1659 to 1681. The modern American Christmas tradition is presented as a deliberate invention by three New Yorkers: Clement Clarke Moore, Washington Irving, and Jonathan Pintard. Moore's 1823 poem "A Visit from St. Nicholas" is recited in full, which the host argues invented a new, family-centered tradition. The analysis cites a 2017 article by Janelle DeWeerd that breaks down the psychology of Christmas into four key areas: tradition, nostalgia, generosity, and escapism. Research on social learning and punishment avoidance explains why people cling to traditions and resist changes like "Happy Holidays" replacing "Merry Christmas." Nostalgia is driven by potent seasonal triggers like specific scents and music, with the controversy over the song "Baby, It's Cold Outside" offered as a modern example. Generosity is linked to the psychological concept of reciprocity, which makes gift-giving rewarding for both giver and receiver. Escapism is facilitated by a psychological process called "transportation," where immersion in holiday stories promotes values like kindness and charity. The host concludes that Christmas has always evolved and been a subject of debate, accommodating both Christian and secular traditions. The perceived "war" stems from the holiday's deep personal and psychological significance to individuals. The tone is educational and conversational, blending historical narrative with psychological analysis. The style is structured, moving from historical facts to a theoretical framework explaining the debate's endurance. Listeners interested in cultural history, the origins of holidays, and social psychology would enjoy this episode. Those seeking a heated debate on modern political rhetoric or a purely supernatural conspiracy theory might find it too academic.

As heard by us

A measured look at Christmas history, public mood, and the pull of alternative explanations.

It treats the War on Christmas as a question of history and public mood, beginning with the 1659 Massachusetts Bay Colony fine for Christmas observance.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If holiday outrage is your thing, this traces the "War on Christmas" back to a 1659 Massachusetts Bay Colony fine and a stranger, older Christmas tradition.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Conspiracy Theoryology