The Short Reign and Mysterious Death of Pope John Paul I

·39 min·3 clips

Conflicting stories about who found Pope John Paul I's body fueled doubts about his sudden death.

A warning comes first. The cold open sets the tone around death, suicide, and what happens when official silence leaves too much room to imagine the worst. Pope Francis appears on Easter Sunday, 2025, blessing an estimated 50,000 people in St. Peter's Square after being hospitalized for bronchitis and pneumonia. The next morning, he is dead. The Vatican gives a clear cause: stroke, coma, and heart failure. That detail matters because the episode uses it as a contrast. Maybe the church learned something from the secrecy around John Paul I's death. Then the story turns back to 1978. Pope Paul VI dies on August 6 from complications tied to a heart attack. Cardinals gather on August 26 for a conclave described as sealed off and allergic to ordinary campaigning. Benelli seems like a real contender, though his age, 57, may count against him in a tradition that often favors older pontiffs. Ducani comes in as the humbler option. The first vote splits. By the third round, he is clearly ahead. The fourth round ends it. With roughly 90 of 111 votes, the cardinals choose him. Ducani does not celebrate. He sits tense and quiet, then says, "may God forgive you for what you have done in my regard." It lands like the kind of strange little detail a mystery feeds on.

As heard by us

A papal mystery that treats secrecy as a pressure system, not a costume.

The episode treats John Paul I's 33-day papacy as a mystery shaped by secrecy, then roots that tension in the 1978 conclave that lifted Albino Luciani, a modest figure who seemed stunned by the office.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If papal secrecy intrigues you, press play on the Vatican case file.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Conspiracy Theories