Conflicted: A History Podcast · Evergreen Podcasts

When Justinian Met Theodora – Part 1

·1 hr 30 min·4 clips

An informant from Antioch arrives on a litter, and Justinian asks, “Who was that?”

1. Conflicted: A History Podcast turns from the 20th century to 6th-century Byzantium and the world of Justinian and Theodora. 2. Zach Cornwell hosts the episode for Conflicted and frames the story as a move into the “distant past” and the so-called Dark Ages. 3. The episode asks what the Byzantine Empire looked like when Justinian met Theodora and why their partnership mattered in late antiquity. 4. Cornwell contrasts the Western Roman collapse in 476 A.D. with Constantinople’s survival as the Eastern Roman Empire. 5. He places the story in Constantinople, today’s Istanbul, and describes the St. Vitale mosaics in Ravenna as the surviving image of Justinian and Theodora. 6. Justinian and Theodora are introduced as emperor and empress, with historians David Potter and James Allen Evans describing their partnership as a remarkable love affair. 7. Their rule is said to face rebellions, wars, court intrigue, and a bubonic plague outbreak. 8. Most of the episode’s evidence comes from Procopius, Justinian’s legal adviser and court historian who later wrote The Secret History. 9. Cornwell calls Procopius a disgruntled employee, and historians Bettany Hughes and James Evans describe the text as hostile and unreliable. 10. The episode argues that the source is still useful because, as Potter puts it, there is “some gold mixed in with the manure.” 11. The narrative shifts to January 521 A.D. and the Hippodrome, a 100,000-seat arena in Constantinople. 12. Cornwell compares the arena’s scale to MetLife Stadium and notes that the crowd treats chariot racing like a citywide event. 13. The Blues and Greens are described as factional identities, not just teams, with support stretching across the empire. 14. Procopius is quoted saying chariot racing gives rise to “madness rather than pleasure” and can bring cities to ruin. 15. Justin is introduced as a 71-year-old emperor whose memory and eyesight are failing. 16. Justinian is shown beside him as a man in his thirties, born Petrus Sebaceus on a pig farm in what is now Serbia. 17. Justinian’s education, work discipline, and Blue allegiance are presented as the tools he uses to build political support before inheriting the throne. 18. The episode’s tone mixes narration, historical quotation, and vivid scene-setting, with Cornwell using modern sports and city references to explain Byzantine life. 19. Listeners interested in Justinian, Theodora, Byzantine politics, and ancient Rome should get the most from it. 20. Listeners wanting a fast modern politics recap should probably skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Conflicted: A History Podcast