Commonwealth Club of California Podcast

Figure It Out…Or Else: Feds to Colorado River States

·31 min·3 clips
The federal government gives seven states until Valentine's Day to agree on drastic water cuts, or it will step in and decide for them.
The conversation begins with the West's unusually warm and dry winter. Arianna Brocious lays out how reduced snowmelt and rain are cutting inflows to the Colorado River, whose water supports seven states and 40 million people. The basin's two major reservoirs are sitting at historic lows. Without a sudden run of snowstorms, the coming year's streamflow forecasts look bleak, putting more pressure on a region already living with drought. The discussion places the current standoff inside a much longer crisis. The river has been under strain for a couple of decades, and climate change is helping drive the decline in water reaching it. States are being asked to reset expectations. The federal government has set February 14 as the deadline for an agreement, after which the Bureau of Reclamation could divide the water among states. Sarah Porter brings the perspective of the Kyle Center for Water Policy at Arizona State University. She argues that an agreement would give water users the certainty they need for decisions that reach far beyond one season. Cities in Central Arizona plan water resources up to 100 years ahead. When a city does not know how much Colorado River water it can count on, Porter says, long-term planning gets much harder, especially when that supply may make up most of its water portfolio. Farmers face a similar bind. They finance crop plans years ahead, and uncertain supplies make those plans harder to make. Porter also explains what this means for tribes. Water can support tribal revenue and agriculture, while uncertainty makes it harder to plan for economic resilience and leaves unresolved when water may not be available. The conversation then turns to litigation. Brocious compares a possible court process to a divorcing couple asking someone else to divide things, and Porter draws on almost 15 years as a litigator to explain how legal action can narrow arguments to the facts, law, risks, and opportunities at stake. She points to disputes between states that reached the U.S. Supreme Court and later settled. The program closes with rumors of a possible short-term deal that could give states more time to figure out how to share less water and stay out of court.

As heard by us

A clear look at how Colorado River uncertainty reaches budgets, crops, tribal revenue, and federal intervention.

The Colorado River crisis comes through as a planning problem as much as a water-policy fight. Seven states and 40 million people are facing dwindling flows, reservoirs at historic lows, and a February 14 deadline after which the Bureau of Reclamation could divide water among…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You will hear how Colorado River uncertainty can freeze plans that cities, farmers, and tribes need to make far into the future.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on