Ep. 455: ANTM Doc, Kylie & Timmy, Hannah Montana, & More

February 24, 2026·1 hr 2 min·5 clips

Tyra Banks is asked what she wants her legacy to be, pauses dramatically, and says ice cream. Not the show. Not modeling. Ice cream. And she apparently now lives in Australia running an ice cream business.

The episode starts in scarcity mode. Emma and Julie say the story buffet is not buffet-ing, and the thin week becomes part of the rhythm instead of a problem to hide. The Alabama Barker warning sets the tone: even the backup topics arrive like shared lore, with the listener expected to know why the name already carries a little charge. It is loose, sometimes very loose, but that is the shape of the show here. The excerpt gets heavier when they move into the ANTM doc. Nostalgia stops being harmless background noise. Tyra Banks is the sticking point, because the show wanted credit for being inclusive and diverse while still asking a more diverse group of girls to fit themselves into the fashion industry's harsh standards. Emma and Julie do not overcomplicate it. The problem is right there: the show challenged the industry in its branding, then taught contestants how to survive inside the same rules. The article gives them a clean way to say it, especially around Banks wanting credit for fighting the fashion industry while coaching contestants to thrive in it. They sit with that without pretending the show had no pull. ANTM mattered to people, which is part of why the critique lands. The success does not make the old format easier to defend. It almost makes it stranger to revisit. Their read stays fan fluent. Even when the point sharpens, it sounds like two friends comparing notes while the memory is still loading, not a formal takedown. The ending has a different texture. Cozy Cliff and My Mello slide into a Skims robe mention, then into the paid endorsement notice, with barely any air between them. For this listen, the best part is the ANTM close read. The product warmth at the end is softer, but not as interesting.

As heard by us

A loose celeb-chat episode finds its footing in a smart, uneasy look back at America's Next Top Model.

Comments by Celebs turns a slow celebrity-news week into a relaxed catch-up that eventually sharpens around the America's Next Top Model docuseries.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

For when the hosts spend a sparse-news episode on what the ANTM docuseries gets right about Tyra.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Comments by Celebs