Comanagers Fantasy Football Show · John Youngblood and Justin Booska

The Pettiest Hall of Fame Vote Ever? - A Fantasy Football Podcast for 2/5

·45 min·2 clips

Bill Belichick missing the Hall of Fame on the first ballot becomes a debate about what the Hall of Fame is worth.

The show opens loose. Jon and Justin jump right into Bill Belichick missing first-ballot Hall of Fame election, and they argue that the vote takes away more from the Hall of Fame than it does from Belichick. They walk through the explanations people are offering, including Spygate, Deflategate, and the North Carolina/Jordan-Hudson situation. They also compare the moment to the Pro Bowl and joke about how little the honor means if Shador Sanders can make it while more qualified options are passed over. From there they turn to coaching hires and wonder whether a move is a bridge situation, a culture situation, or a way to bring in someone with a relationship to Aaron Rogers. Pittsburgh gets its own stretch of the discussion. They talk about ownership insisting the hire was not just because he is a Pittsburgh native, even though the coach's opening press conference leaned hard into growing up as a Pittsburgh fan. They say the fan base has wanted Tomlin gone for years, even if that reaction is silly, and they frame the Steelers as a team that keeps outperforming its roster without ever quite finding the quarterback answer. Jackson Dart comes up as a counterexample that shows a later draft pick can still work out. Shador Sanders gets dragged back into the joke as a fifth-round pick and Pro Bowl example. The episode then shifts into blind-resume comparisons, placing McCarthy alongside Tomlin and Harbaugh while also asking whether prime Aaron Rogers and the Matt LaFleur era change the read on his coaching impact. They do the same with Dak Prescott and the strong Dallas offensive line, suggesting McCarthy got credit for a unit that was already loaded. The Joe Montana comparison is treated as absurd. By the close, they call the Browns a total mess after losing Kevin Stefanski and Jim Schwartz and say the new staff does not look like an upgrade.

As heard by us

A fantasy football argument that turns coaching news into a live board fight.

Bill Belichick missing on the first ballot gives this fantasy-football episode its edge, and Jon Youngblood and Justin Busca use it to argue over what prestige means when football starts grading its own legends.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you care about Belichick's first-ballot miss and the Steelers' coaching churn, hit play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Comanagers Fantasy Football Show