Colorado Matters

Dec. 18, 2025: Deck the halls with 'Garland'

·49 min·4 clips
Ryan Warner revisits a 1963 Judy Garland Christmas special that inspired a decade of Colorado Matters holiday extravaganzas.
Colorado Matters spends its holiday hour with Judy Garland. The show treats the 1963 Christmas special as the spark behind its own annual special of music, storytelling, and comedy, and Ryan Warner places that television moment against December 1963, when the Kennedy assassination made the work of lifting spirits feel especially fraught. The opening has a hard edge. Warner lingers on Garland's performance and on the odd pressure of holiday cheer in that moment before moving into What'll I Do, where Garland's introduction is awkward in the way live television can be awkward. The joke lands a little sideways. He notes that the Carnegie Hall album sold a million copies and brought Garland her first gold record, then lets the riff about records on a needle stand without smoothing it out. The banter stays dry. Warner thanks Scott McCormack and adds a line about federal public-media funding going away later on, which keeps the tribute from feeling too tidy. The episode then turns toward a newer find. Warner says he dug up After the Holidays on YouTube for the 2019 extravaganza, drawn to a song in which a woman asks her beau to wait until after the holidays before breaking up with her. Julie Davis brings it to life. He describes her as a fixture on the Colorado music scene, with collaborations that include Gregory Alan Isaacoff, Nathaniel Rateliff, and Ian Cook, and notes that her current project is Blue Book. Joseph Pope III joins her on stage. Warner introduces him as her husband, and the performance carries the small strain of a song that Davis says she put off because she was anxious and because Judy Garland is an idol. The strain fits the song. The final stretch folds back into the idea that joy has to be focused on and magnified if it is going to hold, which gives the special a plain emotional center. The finish is gentle. Warner thanks the people around him, including Michael Hughes and Kelly Griffin, and then cues the return home to Colorado, not Kansas. The holiday ritual resets itself. By the end, Judy Garland's awkward television warmth and the revived breakup song sit inside one steady seasonal frame.

As heard by us

A holiday radio hour linking Judy Garland to Colorado's annual tradition.

Colorado Matters builds its holiday hour around a 1963 Judy Garland television special, using it as the spark for the station's annual holiday extravaganza.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a holiday listen built around Judy Garland and a live rendition of "After the Holidays," press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on