Cold Cases · Spotify Studios

Dead on the 4th of July: Marilyn Reese Sheppard Pt. 1

·52 min·1 clip

Marilyn fears abandonment and Sam is already cheating on her.

The episode opens with a graphic-content warning because the case involves murder and assault. In the early hours of July 4, 1954, Bay Village mayor Spencer Houck is asleep beside Esther when a call wakes them both. The message is strange enough to send them racing across town. At the Sheppard house, Sam is found in the den, shirtless, clutching his neck, with blood on his pants. He says he woke after Marilyn screamed and that a bushy-haired man attacked him. Esther is sent upstairs to check on Marilyn. The story then moves back to the years before the killing. Sam's work kept him busy, while Marilyn stayed home with Sam Jr. and Coco and managed the house. She also taught Bible classes at the local Methodist church, went bowling, golfing, and even dabbled in ballroom dancing. The show presents her as a vivacious addition to Bay Village. Sam's family was nearby, and the household could afford a part-time housekeeper. That support made the home feel more settled than it had before. The episode also introduces Richard Eberling, a handyman whose behavior is described as peculiar. He greets Marilyn a little too familiarly, which adds another uneasy thread to the account. The Sheppards also socialize with Spencer and Esther Houck. Together the couples buy a boat and teach the neighborhood how to water ski. Their lives are tied to lake parties and potluck dinners. Dawn and Nancy Ahern become close friends as well. The narration then widens into the affair between Sam and Susan Hayes, a 21-year-old medical technician from Bay View Hospital. She often rides with him to work. The flirtation grows into an on-and-off affair from 1951 to 1952. By 1953, people around them are gossiping about it. The episode uses that personal history to build pressure around the murder and to show how quickly a polished suburban life can turn unstable.

As heard by us

A careful true-crime account that keeps the domestic details and the mystery in balance.

The murder of Marilyn is presented as a slow, exacting rewind through an early July morning that should have stayed ordinary and instead turns fatal. It lands best in the concrete details: the 5:40 a.m.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a slow-burn Marilyn Sheppard case file anchored by a 5:40 a.m. phone call.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cold Cases