Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons · Randy Hubbard

Season 4: Episode 9 - Beauty Lost - Murder of Stacey Colbert

January 16, 2025·31 min
Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons opens with Randy Hubbard framing the case through victimology. Lydia Lysko joins him, and they bring in student investigators Donya, Kaylin, Alexa, and Layla to walk through Stacey Colbert's disappearance and death. Stacey was one year from graduation at Ohio State. She lived alone in her own apartment, and on the day she disappeared she came home early from a night in, around 6 p.m. She was packing her suitcases for a conference she had the next week in New York, which gives the case an ordinary starting point before everything goes missing. The students explain that there is very little information between that evening and the point where the case becomes a murder investigation. That missing stretch matters, because the case was not treated as a homicide right away and a lot of the original lead work went cold. The hosts keep coming back to what that means for evidence. Old leads fade. Useful questions are left hanging. The group talks through Stacey's connection to her sorority house and her friends there, and they make clear that there were no issues with that circle. They also place her in the broader college atmosphere, since her apartment was close to Ohio State and still very much part of the downtown Columbus campus orbit. Randy pushes on the neighborhood context, pointing out that a college town on a weekend can make strange sounds easy to dismiss. That observation leads into the practical problem of witnesses who may have heard screaming but did not think it required action. The conversation does not excuse that silence, but it does try to explain how ordinary noise can blur into danger. The episode stays plainspoken about those limits. It does not pretend the record is fuller than it is. Instead, it keeps returning to what can be said with confidence and where the case still falls apart. The result is a careful classroom-style investigation that moves step by step through the facts available to the students. It leaves Stacey as a person with plans, not just a victim in a file.

As heard by us

A careful student-led cold case that keeps Stacey Colbert centered while staying focused on what the record does and does not show.

Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons follows Stacey Colbert's case through victimology, from her return home around 6 p.m. to the point where the investigation becomes a murder case.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a calm, student-led cold case with real-world context.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on