Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons · Randy Hubbard

Season 4: Episode 11 - Trying Her Best - The Murder of Jillian Miles

January 30, 2025·18 min·1 clip
Jillian Miles was described as an outgoing mother who cared deeply for her two children and wanted to provide for them.
The episode opens by saying Jillian Miles is a young woman who got involved in a high-risk lifestyle, but Randy Hubbard and Lydia Lysko keep stressing that what happened to her does not define who she is. They introduce Clara, Avery, and Cassie, all seniors at William Mason High School, and let them lead the case discussion. The students place the shooting around 9 p.m. on February 19, 2013. Neighbors called police after hearing running water and screaming from the duplex at 160 West Parkwood Avenue. Gunshots had also come from the house. Jillian had been upstairs taking a bath or a shower, then went downstairs for unknown reasons and was shot at the bottom of her stairs. Her two kids were in the living room along with their dog. When police arrived, all the doors were locked, and a neighbor saw someone leave through the side door and run away. The discussion then turns back to Jillian herself. The students describe her as a beautiful mother of two. Lisa Miller says Jillian was outgoing and cared deeply about her children. Jillian did not want to work full time, but she wanted to do whatever she could to provide for her kids. Dawn Miles says Jillian loved being independent and wanted to grow up. After moving out, she became more self-confident. The students also say she still had her own personality and her own dreams. They point to a letter Jillian wrote to Sinclair asking to get back into college so she could maybe try to get a degree and get a job. They treat that letter as a sign that she may have realized the situation was not working for her and that she wanted to do better for herself and her kids. The episode closes with Dawn Miles crying at the presentation, the hosts acknowledging the family's grief, and a request for anyone with information to come forward.

As heard by us

A careful student-led look at Jillian Miles that keeps her life ahead of the crime.

Cold Case MHS keeps Jillian Miles, a young mother of two, at the center and spends its time on who she was before she was shot on February 19, 2013.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You get a student-led cold case about Jillian Miles, a grieving family, and a locked-house mystery.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on