Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons · Randy Hubbard

Innocence Lost - The Awful Murder of Devan Duniver

·41 min·2 clips

Devin's body was found 100 yards from the apartment complex in a brush-covered area that searchers had already checked.

Randy Hubbard opens by welcoming listeners back and introducing Paul Berry as a colleague with a long background in forensic work. He talks about the show's three seasons, the steady co-hosts along the way, and the student work that has helped build the podcast. Paul Berry responds with appreciation for the class and for the foundation Hubbard has laid. The discussion then shifts to Devin and the hard question of how the search for a five-year-old unfolded after she was reported missing. The students stay on the timing of the police call. They ask whether seven hours feels like a long delay, and they set that uncertainty against the reality of a five-year-old who really could not fend for herself and the pressure of a stressful home situation with other kids in the household. The episode does not hurry past that tension. It keeps asking how much time had passed, what people knew at the moment, and how the first hours of a search can shape everything that follows. Once police were contacted, a radio call went out to bring in searchers from all over the New Philadelphia area. Because that request went out over the radio, the exact names of the searchers are not easy to track, but the episode makes clear that many people showed up to help. The weather matters here too. The night was warm, between 70 and 80 degrees, and an earlier storm had left the ground wet and covered with debris. That kind of detail gives the search a physical shape. The students also discuss the search dogs that were brought in voluntarily rather than by the police department. One dog traced a path from a neighbor's house where Devin was confirmed to have gone, returned to the apartment, and then followed an elaborate route to the side entry door of a house near the garage. A second dog followed the exact same pathway hours later. The route itself starts to feel like part of the investigation. The episode asks who lived in that house, why the path mattered, and what the dogs may have been pointing toward. It keeps the uncertainty visible instead of smoothing it away. That is the show's strength here: the students are trying to work the case carefully, step by step, while leaving room for the parts they still do not know.

As heard by us

A careful student-led cold-case search that keeps the unanswered parts in view.

The episode follows a student-led cold-case conversation about the disappearance of Devan Duniver, and its strength lies in how steadily the group works the case: what police were told, how long the family waited, how the search unfolded, and where the timeline still leaves room…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a case broken down from report to search to the trail that followed, press play.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons