Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons · Randy Hubbard

Destructive Mentor - The murder of Raymond Wells III

February 2, 2024·16 min·1 clip
Raymond was trying to leave his gang to join the military, while the gang leader had interest in his girlfriend.
Randy Hubbard introduces Gabby as co-host. He frames Raymond's death around young men who want guidance, and Gabby answers from that same lane with a promise to help put people's stories back out there. That framing stays personal. The discussion keeps returning to fathers, older brothers, coaches, teachers, parents of friends, and other people who can set a standard, then asks what happens when that support is missing and someone with bad intentions steps in. Raymond is the case at the center. The title, Destructive Mentor, fits the way the episode links the murder to belonging, pressure, and the pull of the wrong kind of influence. The students then move into the cars. They compare a 1981 Buick Regal with a Buick Riviera and argue that the Regal would have made it easier to stab Raymond because of the front middle seat and the tighter space. They favor the Regal. That theory is tied to the number of wounds, which they say was 27, and to the idea that other passengers would have been harder to avoid in the Riviera. The police work sounds messy. They describe a long, hard investigation that included the arrest of one 16-year-old shortly after the murder happened, but an alibi kept that from going anywhere. They kept talking to people. Gang members, girlfriends, and family all come up, and the story kept shifting without giving investigators enough evidence to pin down one account. One call stands out. A person of interest called Raymond's girlfriend and told her Raymond was dead before police had even told Raymond's mother, and the episode treats that as a sign of leaked information or prior knowledge. That same person also made a pass at Raymond's girlfriend. The students use that connection to argue he may have been directly tied to the crime, or at least close enough to know more than he should have. There is also a brief thread about THC in Raymond's body and a possible route toward Sharon Woods. Even there, the episode stays in the space of we think and maybe, which matches its classroom style better than a polished detective script. The ending looks ahead to episode seven and Angela Hanaway. It closes by moving from Raymond's case to a broader warning about the lifestyle that put her and other women like her in the presence of an addictive killer.

As heard by us

A student-led murder case anchored by role models, car layout, and stubborn clues.

Cold Case MHS: Monsters and Demons frames Raymond Wells III's murder around a destructive mentor and spends its opening stretch on something sturdier than the crime itself: young men looking for guidance, belonging, and role models.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If a student-led murder theory and a Buick Regal seat layout sound like your night, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on