Starmer, Mandelson & HMT: why Gordon Brown has never been more relevant

February 14, 2026·17 min·1 clip

Why does a Valentine's Day podcast dive into Gordon Brown and Tony Blair's famous love-hate relationship?

This special Valentine's Day episode of Coffee House Shots examines the complex relationship between Gordon Brown and Tony Blair, prompted by recent headlines involving Peter Mandelson. Hosted by the show's presenter, the guest is James McIntyre, author of the new biography "Power with Purpose" on Gordon Brown. McIntyre argues Brown's reputation has improved since leaving office, with Labour Party polling showing him as well-respected compared to other living former prime ministers. The discussion centers on the evolution of Brown's relationship with Peter Mandelson, against whom serious allegations have recently been made. McIntyre's book details a poignant moment where Brown called Mandelson to offer condolences after the death of Mandelson's mother in 2006, even during a period of feud. The conversation explores the broader "love-hate" dynamic and "friendship-turned-sort-of-rivalry" between Brown and Tony Blair that defined the New Labour era. McIntyre positions his book as a reappraisal of Brown, noting several existing biographies but feeling the time was right for another look. A key insight is that Brown's act of calling Mandelson in 2006 reveals the deeply complicated and personal nature of their political partnership. The episode suggests Brown would be "disgusted" with the recent allegations against Mandelson, as indicated in the book's concluding pages. The timing of the book's release alongside the "Mandelson saga" is presented as coincidental, though it frames the current discussion. The analysis implies that these personal histories are crucial for understanding the characters and lingering tensions within the Labour Party's recent past. The tone is analytical and conversational, blending current political scandal with historical biography. The style is interview-based, with the host prompting the guest to elaborate on themes from his research. Listeners interested in Labour Party history, the psychology of political relationships, or the legacy of New Labour would find this episode compelling. Those seeking a discussion solely on contemporary policy might find the historical and personal focus less directly relevant.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Coffee House Shots