How Top Leaders Influence Great Teamwork, with Scott Keller

December 29, 2025·39 min·1 clip

The greatest basketball team ever assembled lost their first game on purpose - and it made them unstoppable.

Scott Keller, senior partner at McKinsey and co-author of 'CEO Excellence,' shares insights from studying the world's top leaders and their approach to teamwork. He begins with the forest ecosystem analogy, explaining how great teams have visible mechanics but more importantly, invisible dynamics that determine success. The centerpiece story involves the 1992 Olympic Dream Team losing their first scrimmage to college players - a loss their coach Chuck Daly deliberately allowed to happen to shift the team's psychology from complacency to hunger. This illustrates how top leaders focus on shaping team psychology rather than just managing logistics. Keller outlines how exceptional CEOs staff their teams, looking for two key qualities: aptitude (specifically the ability to balance short-term and long-term thinking) and attitude (putting the organization before personal interests). He describes various CEO approaches to creating 'one team' cultures, from taglines like 'Team Caterpillar' to Lilac Asher's 'fist' metaphor where nothing gets between the fingers. The conversation explores a practical influence framework using a memorable cartwheel exercise that demonstrates four levers for behavior change: role modeling, storytelling, enabling mechanisms, and building skills and confidence. Keller emphasizes that top leaders are both fair and fast when dealing with team members, giving people proper support before making personnel decisions. He shares the ultimatum game psychology experiment to explain why fairness matters more than outcomes in leadership transitions. The discussion covers how CEOs stay connected throughout their organizations through skip-level meetings and transparent communication while maintaining appropriate distance to make objective decisions. Keller reveals two key insights that changed his thinking: first, that the best leaders focus on developing B players into A players rather than just quickly removing C players; and second, that successful CEOs distill their entire culture strategy into one powerful idea rather than multiple priorities. Examples include Satya Nadella's 'growth mindset' at Microsoft and various other single-focus cultural initiatives. The conversation concludes with practical advice about identifying the highest value-creating roles in an organization and spending time accordingly.

As heard by us

A practical look at how leaders can shape teamwork by changing behavior, not just hoping for it.

Scott Keller frames teamwork as something leaders can shape directly, not as a vague ideal that happens on its own. The cartwheel example gives the discussion an easy entry point before moving into role modeling, storytelling, and the pressure points that influence group…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If your team needs more than slogans, this rebroadcast shows how top leaders can influence real teamwork.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Coaching for Leaders