Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine - The Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine Podcast

How do physical contact, injury, and penalties differ between boys and girls youth ice hockey?

·28 min·2 clips
Only 5.4% of head contacts in girls' hockey resulted in penalties, despite a zero-tolerance policy.
The episode starts with a study. Dr. Erin Hammer frames the paper as a video analysis of physical contact and suspected injury rates in female versus male youth ice hockey, published in the May 2023 issue of CJSM. Ryland Williamson is the first guest. He describes the research group at the Sport Injury Prevention Research Centre at the University of Calgary, where the work aims to reduce injuries across youth hockey and other sports in Canada. The interview stays close to the study and its prevention angle. Hammer asks direct questions about the program, the study logic, and what the findings might mean, instead of treating the numbers as the whole answer. Physicality becomes the next focus. Williamson and Curl discuss how checking shapes the men's game, while the women's game has no body checking but still brings plenty of contact and pace. Curl is careful about the distinction. She says the women's game is not simply softer, and that removing the fear of a huge hit can make players more creative and less rushed with the puck. Skill matters here. That part of the conversation argues that the value of hockey does not depend on big open-ice collisions, even if physical play remains central to speed, pressure, and positioning. The episode also widens the lens. The discussion touches on how study findings about checking and head contact in youth hockey sit alongside the realities of how the sport is actually played on ice. Policy enters near the end. The closing exchange looks at how other countries are changing their approaches and asks whether player safety is being kept in mind when officials rethink how physical the game should be. The tone stays measured. Instead of overclaiming, the episode keeps separating evidence from assumption and lets the implications surface for listeners interested in youth hockey, injury prevention, and the role of physicality. That restraint is the point. The result is a careful clinical conversation about contact, injury, and the shape of youth hockey, grounded in research and lived experience.

As heard by us

A careful look at contact, injury, and what youth hockey calls physical.

This journal-club style discussion stays tightly focused on a single question: how physical contact and suspected injury rates differ in female versus male youth ice hockey.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want a grounded read on physical contact and suspected injury rates in youth hockey?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on