Claret & Blue Podcast

What we really think about Villa vs Newcastle in the FA Cup

·21 min·2 clips
Would Aston Villa fans accept an FA Cup exit if it meant keeping star player Anana fit for the Champions League race?
The presenters discuss the FA Cup tie between Villa and Newcastle. They look at whether Villa should use the match to give other players a chance and freshen the side. Alisson comes up as someone they would like to see involved. From there, the conversation moves to Newcastle's position. The presenters think Newcastle may be without Gemma Rice again, and they weigh whether Newcastle might take the tie more seriously than Villa. Newcastle being out of the Carabao Cup feeds into that thinking. The club is also due to play in the Champions League play-off knockouts, while sitting a few points from the Premier League's European places keeps the league in the picture too. The presenters see Europe as a likely target for Newcastle and compare that ambition with Villa's own aims. Newcastle's trophy from last season changes the mood around the FA Cup as well. They consider a path to back-to-back silverware through Champions League progress and the FA Cup, even if Newcastle finish 10th in the league, and suggest Newcastle fans would take that. Jacob Ramsey's return to Villa Park brings the focus back onto the teams. They ask whether he would start, especially with Newcastle carrying injuries. The presenters then widen the point to the choices facing both managers. One imagined version has the captains agreeing to protect their players and get through the night without damage. The other is a chaotic, end-to-end game. The discussion closes on the hope of a win, but also the worry that a serious injury to an important player would sour it.

As heard by us

A Villa-Newcastle preview where rotation, Europe, and injury risk pull the FA Cup tie in different directions.

The FA Cup meeting with Newcastle is framed as a question of priorities, with Villa's urge to freshen the side weighed against the sense that Newcastle may give the tie a harder push.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Villa-Newcastle cup stakes with rotation talk and injury nerves in the same conversation.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on