Civilization and Climate · Ellsworth Huntington

015 - The Shifting Of Climatic Zones

·42 min·2 clips
Penck says climatic change is an alternate shifting of the climatic zones.
1. Civilization and Climate, Chapter 14, focuses on “The Shifting of Climatic Zones” and the climate-history problem raised by the previous chapter. 2. The chapter is framed by the author and recorded by Leon Harvey for LibriVox, which places the argument in a public-domain reading context. 3. The core question is whether civilization followed climate, despite three objections from ancient nations, the American Indians, and Europeans in northern Australia. 4. The first line of evidence comes from ruins, old roads, dry springs, terraced fields, and irrigation canals in Asia, Africa, and America. 5. The author rejects deforestation and progressive irrigation as complete explanations, citing contradictory rainfall measurements and places like southeastern Syria and Chinese Turkestan. 6. He then proposes pulsatory climatic change, with alternating wet and dry phases rather than a single one-way trend. 7. A dated sequence is given for Western Asia and northern Africa, including a dry period around 1200 B.C., wetter conditions in Herodotus’s time, and another dry peak around 650 A.D. 8. The same sequence is extended with a recovery around 1000 A.D., a bad period in the 13th century, and minor fluctuations since the 14th century. 9. The discussion then shifts to glacial studies, varves, and about 50 moraines reported by F.B. Taylor and others. 10. Tree rings become the main measuring tool in California, where A. E. Douglas and the author use ring thickness to track annual water supply. 11. The California material includes measurements on about 450 sequoia stumps taken in 1911 and 1912 under the Carnegie Institution of Washington. 12. The sequoias ranged from 250 to nearly 3,250 years old, and the author says the graph matches the Asian curve closely in broad outline. 13. Owens Lake provides a second test, with H.S. Gale’s salt-balance estimate giving 4,200 years for chlorine, 3,500 for sodium, and an adjusted overflow date of 2,000 to 2,500 years ago. 14. The lake record includes four series of strands, a large gravel beach at the outlet level, and later wet and dry phases around 650 A.D., 1000 A.D., 1250 A.D., and 1350 A.D. 15. The 14th century is treated as a notably stormy period, with floods in France, severe winter ice in northern Europe, and heavy summer rains in England. 16. Mono Lake and other western lakes are used to reinforce the claim that the climate fluctuated irregularly but in step across nearby regions. 17. Penck is introduced as a careful glacial scholar who argued that climatic zones shift, with lakes, dunes, and snow lines changing on the poleward and equatorial sides of desert belts. 18. The chapter then applies that model to the Maya in Yucatan and Guatemala, where forest, malaria, and lowland farming difficulties are contrasted with major sculpture, architecture, astronomy, and writing. 19. The tone is argumentative and cumulative, with long evidence chains, repeated comparisons, and explicit references to figures and measured curves. 20. Listeners interested in archaeology, climate history, and historical geography will get the most from it, while readers wanting a short narrative or a light overview may skip it.

As heard by us

A thesis-heavy chapter, but its evidence keeps the climatic argument grounded.

The chapter pushes the book's main climatic hypothesis forward and puts it through three objections: ancient civilizations in places now described as relatively unstimulating, American Indians who did not develop a high civilization even in favorable climates, and Europeans in…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow the evidence for shifting climatic zones and the climate hypothesis behind civilization.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on