City of Supers: An Improv Superhero Comedy · Connors Brothers

61 - Sharing Our Feelings with Scaredy Cat

March 26, 2025·49 min
Donnie opens alone because Beck is still holed up in the doghouse. He spends the first stretch explaining that Beck has dug in, left notes under the door, and made the building’s first floor unusable because of the smell. Daniel arrives at the door and quickly drags the room back toward old villain business. Donnie pushes him on how he went from Skeletron’s henchman to this unclear new status. Daniel tries to explain the split. The show keeps wobbling between Skeletron and Skeletrax because even the names refuse to settle. Donnie and Daniel both act like they have homework, and the joke is that neither of them can keep the facts clean. Scaredy Cat gets folded in as a vigilante who is close enough to a cop to make the category messy. Daniel says they are up against Skeletron’s most hated hero or nemesis, Skeletrax, and the conversation immediately gets worse in a good way. The duo lean into the confusion instead of fixing it. They describe Skeletrax as skeleton bottom and meaty on top, which only deepens the stupidity of the conflict. Daniel notes that the henchmen are dressed as leopards. Cat is a big theme for him. Donnie and Daniel both say they were more frog guys, which opens another side road. The scene keeps stacking tiny corrections on top of each other. It feels less like a polished interview than a negotiation between bad memory and worse superhero logistics. The bit keeps moving because every attempt to clarify the world creates another contradiction. By the end, Daniel is still pleading to be taken back, and Donnie is still trying to keep the podcast standing. The episode closes with the familiar sign-off, the ratings plug, and the social and email reminders.

As heard by us

Donnie carries the episode while Daniel's return sends City of Supers into the kind of chaos it does best.

City of Supers keeps moving because Donnie has to carry the show while Beck stays shut away, slipping notes through the door and leaving the upstairs mess hanging.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a superhero interview that veers into a chaotic henchman exit interview and never settles down.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on