Christian Woman Leadership Podcast with Esther Littlefield & Holly Cain · Esther Littlefield

224: How to Communicate in Disagreement and the Difference Between Healthy and Dangerous Deconstruction with Joel Muddamalle

·1 hr 1 min·4 clips
Joel says some ideas should be “received,” some “redeemed,” and some “rejected,” instead of treated as one package.
1. Christian Woman Leadership Podcast episode 194 features Joel Udamalle on humble theology, disagreement, and deconstruction. 2. Esther Littlefield and Holly Cain host Joel Udamalle, who has a PhD in biblical theology and oversees theology and research at Proverbs 31 Ministries. 3. The episode asks how Christian leaders can hold convictions without turning theological differences into pride or division. 4. Joel describes growing up in an Indian immigrant family, being raised by his grandmother and three aunts, and learning from strong women. 5. He explains that he moved from worship leadership and church planting into theology work after seminary and organizational psychology study. 6. Joel says Proverbs 31 Ministries gave him work on app study guides, Lisa’s book and Bible study projects, and Therapy and Theology with Lisa Turkers and Jim Kress. 7. Esther introduces a recent Instagram post where Joel discussed complementarian and egalitarian disagreement with the line, “I could be wrong on some or all of this.” 8. Joel says theology is “thinking God’s thoughts after him,” which makes humility necessary because God is limitless and people are limited. 9. He warns that brilliant scholars can still weaponize theology through pride, manipulation, or intellectual superiority. 10. Joel says disagreement should not become an “I win or they win” contest because “we all lose” when unity is abandoned. 11. He compares a faithful theologian to Jacob after wrestling with God, saying the limp becomes a sign of presence and humility. 12. Joel says a theologian “without a limp” is a warning sign, and he jokingly says followers should unfollow him if he starts swaggering. 13. For seeing multiple sides, Joel points to books, libraries, and the Zondervan Counterpoints series as practical tools. 14. He names NT Wright, James Dunn, Eugene Peterson, and Andrew Murray as writers who can challenge a reader’s assumptions. 15. Joel says podcasts can help too, and he names Preston Sprinkle’s Theology in the Raw as an example of hearing different perspectives. 16. He adds a footnote: traditions have beauty, but they become dangerous when treated as “the framework” instead of a framework. 17. Joel says he starts new research projects by writing down his presuppositions, then literally putting them in the corner of his office. 18. He explains that after researching opposing positions, he usually comes away with greater gratitude for the position he disagrees with. 19. The conversation feels like a long-form interview with theological nuance, a lot of back-and-forth, and repeated self-correction around labels. 20. Listeners who like thoughtful Christian leadership conversations will want this; listeners wanting quick certainty about doctrinal labels may skip it.

As heard by us

A steady guide to disagreement, conviction, and disciplined questioning.

This episode looks at how to disagree without turning every disagreement into a fight, while also taking serious theological study seriously. The guest is strongest when he walks through his method: write down the view already in hand, set it aside, and keep studying as other…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When disagreement feels personal, this gives you a steadier way to think.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on