Chilling Tales for Dark Nights: A Horror Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast · Chilling Entertainment, LLC & Studio71

404: vil Idol Resurrection (Playing for Your Soul) - Chilling Tales for Dark Nights

·39 min·3 clips
Learn the terrifying rules of a game where one wrong answer to the devil could cost you everything.
Chilling Tales for Dark Nights opens with Steve Taylor welcoming listeners back to another chapter of Evil Idol Resurrection. The episode is the second installment in a five-part run that revisits standout performances from past Evil Idol competitions. It pulls the archive into something a little more haunted. The show also points listeners to Evil Idol 2025, which is running through the new year, with round two of the season, where the audience decides who advances. At the center is a game with a devil who always starts by asking a question, anything from obscure trivia to a riddle or an intensely personal inquiry. He never says whether you were right or wrong. After you answer, you get one question back. If your answer was correct, he responds as honestly and accurately as he can. If it was wrong, he is free to lie. Then he asks another question, and the cycle keeps going until you quit. The rules sound simple, but the devil never offers easy questions, and the game is built to throw you off balance. Around that, the episode reminds listeners to vote on YouTube, subscribe, ring the bell, leave reviews, follow on Spotify, and join the membership program for ad-free content, early releases, and exclusive stories. It ends with a quiet sign-off.

As heard by us

A devil's game, framed with formal late-night polish and steady dread.

The episode returns to Evil Idol Resurrection and keeps its tension inside a devil's question-and-response game. Steve Taylor opens it in a formal late-night broadcast tone, and that framing does a lot of the work.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a devil story where the rules do the damage.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on