Chasing Hazel's Tales - A Family History Podcast · Kimberly McLaughlin & Laura Ireland - Music by Andrew Mclaughlin

Ep 29 - Sleepy Hollow: Family, Folklore and the Headless Horseman.

·38 min·4 clips
Kim admits she's never been into Halloween, but is suddenly excited to travel to Sleepy Hollow where her Dutch ancestors are from.
Kim and Laura start with the weather, because of course they do. They note that Maine has survived two tropical storms in the past two weeks, and Laura's lemon tree has taken a beating. That small detail sets the easy, conversational tone before the family history work gets going. The discussion shifts to a family line in the Sleepy Hollow area of Westchester County. From there, the trail leads to Canada, where the family married into another line. The hosts keep the story tied to records, places, and relationships rather than letting it drift into guesswork. Jemima Bellier comes into view, and the hosts pause on the name. They mention that some records list her as Jemmy, which they clearly enjoy. That fits the show's habit of treating old names as clues worth noticing, not just labels on a page. Stephen Bellier and Elizabeth Flewelling appear as part of the line, along with Hendrick Bellier as an earlier ancestor. The focus stays on what can be linked from the records and how the family line develops across generations. The uncertainty stays visible where it should. The episode also returns to old Dirk Storm, whom the hosts had discussed in an earlier episode. They reference his book and the family's emigration from Holland in 1624, which widens the frame beyond the immediate New Brunswick line. That connection gives the story a longer historical reach without pushing the evidence too far. A side note about Priscilla Presley, formerly Bullier, adds one more genealogical tangent. The hosts mention that the Bullier family has an interesting business story tied to New York or New Jersey, though they leave that for another day. It is the kind of aside that shows how one surname can open into several different histories. By the end, the episode is less about folklore than about lineage. Sleepy Hollow becomes one starting point in a broader trail through Canadian marriages, Dutch roots, and older family connections. The pace stays gentle throughout, with the hosts sounding like people working through the puzzle in real time.

As heard by us

A relaxed family-history episode that follows a Dutch-descended line through names, records, and recurring clues.

This episode follows a family-history trail from Westchester County to New Brunswick, and the appeal is in the details that do not quite line up at first. The Dutch-descended line, the surname shifts, and the repeated returns to older clues give the search some shape.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Follow one family line from Sleepy Hollow-area roots to New Brunswick names.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on