Cauldron Convos - a Somewhat Funny Paranormal Mysteries & Science Fiction Podcast · Kayla Cauldron

The Unholy Secrets of Vatican City: Whispering Shadows and Eerie Echoes of the Supernatural

·32 min·2 clips

The Apostolic Penitentiary was kept secret until 2009 and handles attempts to assassinate the Pope.

Vatican City is introduced as an independent city-state inside Rome, Italy. It is tiny, and the show uses that scale to make it feel eerie instead of quaint. Ancient stone walls, cobblestones, and twilight do most of the heavy lifting on mood. St. Peter's Basilica is described as sinking into darkness. The Vatican Museums turn into a maze of whispers after nightfall. Painted portraits seem watchful. Sculptures begin to feel like they might move. The hosts then pivot from atmosphere to exorcism lore. Father Gabriel Amorth appears as the Vatican's chief exorcist. The conversation pokes fun at how chief exorcist sounds like an absurd title. The numbers get checked aloud and immediately become the real story. One host lays out the claim that he performed approximately 160,000 exorcisms over 60 years. That turns into rough math, and the math makes the whole thing sound impossible. The hosts keep circling the idea that most people who seek priests are not actually possessed. They suggest that someone else must be filtering out the non-demonic cases first. Even then, the scale still feels ridiculous. The episode keeps asking whether the Church is telling the whole truth. It does this with a straight face only briefly. The tone snaps back into jokes before the tension can settle. Near the end, the Vatican's catacombs and secret archives come up as more places where the weird might live. The archives are described as spanning 53 miles and holding 35,000 volumes and documents. The show then goes fully off the rails with a joke about a first edition Bible signed by Jesus and other blasphemous nonsense. It closes by widening the Vatican into a larger mystery, with the hosts inviting more comments and more digging later.

As heard by us

A chaotic Vatican tour that keeps asking who is telling the truth.

This episode turns Vatican City into a tight, uneasy pressure cooker, with ancient stone, valuable artifacts, and the feeling that old secrets never stay buried for long.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Want Vatican lore with jokes, exorcisms, and zero reverence?

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Cauldron Convos - a Somewhat Funny Paranormal Mysteries & Science Fiction Podcast