Capital Allocators – Inside the Institutional Investment Industry · Ted Seides – Allocator and Asset Management Expert

[REPLAY] Morgan Housel – Same as Ever

·58 min·5 clips

Morgan Housel's book sold 5,000 copies initially but now sells 5,000 per day—a tail event he never saw coming.

Ted opens by playing a clip from his first interview with Morgan, recorded just before The Psychology of Money launched, where Ted predicted it would be a bestseller and Morgan feared he was jinxing it. Morgan describes the surreal arc: the first print run was 5,000 copies, which seemed optimistic, yet the book now sells roughly 5,000 copies per day and has moved 4.5 million copies total in three and a half years. He reflects that tail outcomes -- like this -- are by definition unpredictable, and notes that 20% of things in his life got better, 60% stayed the same, and 20% got worse (mainly expectations for future work, since everything is now measured against a 4.5 million copy benchmark). The origin story of Same As Ever begins with a book called The Great Depression: A Diary by Benjamin Roth, a 1930s bankruptcy attorney in Youngstown, Ohio. Reading Roth's 1932 entries about greedy bankers, hyperinflation fears, and economic anxiety, Morgan noticed every single word matched 2008 perfectly. Two pages later Roth noted the same thing about 1894. The insight crystallized: the actors and details of financial crises change, but human behavior -- how people respond to greed, fear, uncertainty, and risk -- is the same movie playing on repeat for hundreds of years. Combined with frustration at financial forecasting's poor track record, Morgan decided to stop predicting what will change and instead focus exclusively on what never changes. A central theme is storytelling. Morgan traces his appreciation for narrative to a college economics professor who taught entirely through 60-minute stories with no textbooks or formulas -- and from whom Morgan retained more than from any other class combined. As a financial writer, he realized that dumping data and PE ratios produces immediate reader abandonment, while a well-told story holds attention and changes behavior. His favorite example is Ken Burns, who is not a historian but a storyteller so skilled he aligns a narrator's word choices to specific beats in the background music. Applied to investing, Morgan argues Warren Buffett's underrated superpower is communication: his ability to tell a compelling story about what he owns and why has given him a more stable, trusting investor base than performance alone would warrant. Morgan and Ted discuss a bet they made before Same As Ever was published: Ted took the over on 100,000 copies, Morgan took the under -- not because the number was small in absolute terms (selling 100,000 copies of a finance book is a grand slam) but because relative to 4.5 million, expectations had become distorted. Five weeks post-publication, they are closing in on 100,000. Morgan reflects on the people his success has opened doors to: Howard Marks, who comes across as a genuinely humble normal person whose wisdom only reveals itself in conversation, and anonymous ultra-wealthy families who have legally scrubbed their names from the internet to preserve normal social relationships for themselves and their heirs -- whose children Morgan found to be the most grounded he had ever met among the mega-wealthy. On fame, Morgan describes hitting the sweet spot of having a notable name without a recognizable face, passing the "grocery store test." He describes being recognized twice a month versus a famous-faced acquaintance who is recognized every 30 seconds. His next book is called The Art of Spending Money, focusing on how to use money as a tool for a better life -- a topic he considers harder than it looks, because the knee-jerk more-is-better assumption is only about 20% true. Closing questions reveal that Morgan is more anxious and worst-case-scenario-oriented in real life than his zen-seeming writing suggests; that John Reeves of Motley Fool and Craig Shapiro of Collaborative Fund are his two most influential career mentors, both for taking bets on him when they had no reason to; and that the happiest moment of his career was learning Jason Zweig of the Wall Street Journal would review Psychology of Money honestly -- and seeing the first sentence, which he has framed on his wall, calling it the best and most original finance book in years.

As heard by us

A steady case for patience, compounding, and the limits that shape durable results.

Morgan Housel sits down with Ted Seides for a discussion of what tends not to change in markets and in life, with Housel's latest book, Same As Ever, serving as the anchor.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want Morgan Housel at full stride, with the conversation allowed to breathe, start here.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Capital Allocators – Inside the Institutional Investment Industry