Canadian True Crime · Kristi Lee | Canadian True Crime

The Twisted Story of Sergeant John Wilson [replay]

March 13, 2026·1 hr 3 min·6 clips
Mary finds a love letter from Jessie in John's pocket, forcing him to confess their secret affair.
1. Canadian True Crime presents 'The Murderous Mountie,' a two-part archive replay originally named the number eight podcast episode in Canada on Apple Podcasts for 2023, based on hundreds of pages of archival documents from Library and Archives Canada. 2. Host Amber Minogue adapted a narrative written by Toronto true crime author Nate Henley, who combed through the complete archival file; Scottish voice actors read excerpts from the original letters. 3. The episode's core thesis is how Sergeant John Wilson, a chronic failure and congenital liar, used WWI-era chaos and bureaucratic opportunity to build an elaborate double life that ended in murder. 4. John Wilson and Mary Hutchison met as young employees at a drapery company in Carluke, near Glasgow; they married in 1908 and had a son George in 1909 and a daughter Helen born while John had already emigrated to Canada. 5. Wilson left Scotland for Canada in 1911 after a business bankruptcy, promising to send for Mary once he was established; he failed at tomato farming near Prince Albert after a 1914 hailstorm wiped out his entire crop. 6. Wilson was rejected by the Canadian military on physical grounds but accepted into the Royal Northwest Mounted Police in 1914, assigned to Blaine Lake, Saskatchewan, partly because WWI demands for conscription enforcement created a surge in recruitment. 7. At Blaine Lake, Wilson met 16-year-old Jessie Patterson when her father — who owned a horse-boarding stable where Wilson kept his Mountie horse — invited the 30-year-old constable to dinner. 8. Wilson contracted tuberculosis in late 1917, took a discharge from the Mounties, and moved into the Patterson family home, where Jessie nursed him through the winter; he later wrote, 'I lay awake in bed trying to make up my mind to leave her for her sake.' 9. When Jessie's parents confronted Wilson about rumours he was already married, he claimed he was divorced, adding that divorce papers were 'on their way' — a lie he maintained for over a year. 10. Wilson forged a deathbed letter supposedly from his dying sister in Glasgow, calling Mary a gold digger who forced him into marriage and claiming Wilson's own son George was not his biological child. 11. A second forged letter, ostensibly from 75-year-old Reverend Francis M. Huxwell, echoed the same details and bizarrely endorsed Wilson abandoning his wife; the narrator notes a Scottish person would never refer to money in 'dollars.' 12. Mary Wilson, having received no letter or money from John since April 1917, sailed the U-boat-patrolled Atlantic in April 1918 without warning him, arriving in Halifax on April 12, 1918. 13. In a startling coincidence, Mary's first call to the Prince Albert RNWMP detachment reached John Wilson in person — he happened to be there that day applying to join a wartime cavalry unit and was visibly shaken by the superintendent's handover of the phone. 14. John reconnected with Mary and the couple moved into a Regina boarding house; he largely ignored her except when wanting sex, and their boarding house landlady noted he refused to be seen with Mary during daylight hours. 15. Mary discovered a love letter from Jessie in John's coat pocket, confronted him, and he dismissed Jessie as a foolish young woman who mistook friendship for love — then Mary found a second letter proving he had continued the relationship. 16. Throughout the summer of 1918 Wilson wrote romantic letters to Jessie — including 'I will kiss you this time whether you slap me or not' — while living with his pregnant wife Mary, who sank into a deep depression. 17. The episode is narrated in a measured, documentary style with archival quotes read verbatim, including letters from Wilson, Mary's sister Elizabeth, and RNWMP internal memos, providing a strong sense of primary-source authenticity. 18. Wilson accepted a sub-inspector posting with the Dominion Police in Saskatoon in late 1918, leaving pregnant Mary in Regina with a vague promise to buy them a house — the setup for the murder in Part 2. 19. True crime fans interested in WWI-era Canadian social history, archival research, and long-form narrative podcasting will find this compelling. 20. Listeners who prefer contemporary cases or short-form episodes without historical context may want to skip this one.

As heard by us

Archive letters and wartime deceit make this replay slow to start but hard to shake.

This replay leans on its archive material well. The Library and Archives Canada file, the love letters, the forged letters, and the police and court records give the wartime triangle real texture, and the First World War setting carries its own weight without needing much help.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want a First World War love triangle built from an archival file of letters, forged notes, police memos, and a brutal murder.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on