Canadian True Crime · Kristi Lee | Canadian True Crime

The Twisted Story of Sergeant John Wilson [2]

March 14, 2026·1 hr 2 min·5 clips
John Wilson claims his shotgun accidentally discharged, blowing off Mary's head as she sat in the car.
1. Canadian True Crime's 'The Murderous Mountie' Part 2 covers the murder of 32-year-old pregnant Mary Wilson by her husband Sergeant John Wilson on September 27, 1918, north of Saskatoon, and the investigation that followed. 2. The episode is narrated by the host based on research by Toronto author Nate Henley using original archival documents from Library and Archives Canada, with RNWMP and Saskatchewan Provincial Police memos quoted verbatim throughout. 3. The central question is how John Wilson maintained his deception after committing murder — and how a grieving Scottish family, not the police, initiated the investigation that exposed him. 4. On the morning of September 28, 1918, farm workers found Wilson drunk beside a burning Grey Dort on a rural road north of Saskatoon; blood stains on his satchel were dismissed by Wilson as coming from a goose he claimed to have shot. 5. Wilson married Jessie Patterson just two days after the murder, on September 29, 1918, in a Saskatoon ceremony performed by Reverend Wiley Clark — with Jessie's brother James Patterson present as witness. 6. To conceal Mary's disappearance, Wilson wrote three separate letters: a forged letter pretending to be Mary requesting her luggage be forwarded, a letter to the landlady claiming Mary had nearly died of Spanish flu, and a grotesque letter to Mary's sister Elizabeth describing fictional medical bills and falsely assuring them the baby had survived. 7. Wilson's performance with the Dominion Police in Saskatoon continued to deteriorate — his colleagues could not access expense funds after his appointment, and his open drinking on the job was documented. 8. When the Dominion Police disbanded after the November 1918 armistice, Wilson reapplied to the RNWMP and was posted to Vancouver in early 1919 to investigate communist infiltrators among Eastern European immigrants. 9. Back in Scotland, Mary's sister Elizabeth Craig grew alarmed when Mary's regular letters home stopped abruptly in late September 1918; she wrote to the RNWMP Assistant Commissioner in April 1919, noting the family had also sent John £100 that he never acknowledged. 10. Family friend Mrs. Lang, having traveled to Canada, tried to contact Wilson through the Mounties in Regina and was told first that Mary had recovered from the flu, then that she had been badly injured in a car accident — two incompatible stories that Elizabeth reported to authorities. 11. Elizabeth Craig's April 1919 letter to the RNWMP characterized John Wilson as 'a plausible liar' and requested the Mounties check on her sister. 12. A sergeant dispatched to Wilson's Vancouver address noticed that the young woman living with him bore no resemblance to the photograph Elizabeth had provided — triggering a formal bigamy investigation. 13. Wilson sold the murder weapon — a 12-gauge double-barrelled shotgun — to a second-hand goods store in Vancouver, signing a false name in the ledger and accepting $23; investigators later tracked it down and bought it back for $50. 14. Staff Sergeant Herbert Darling of Regina found Wilson's second marriage certificate dated September 29, 1918, and confirmed that Mary's uncollected luggage had been sitting in Prince Albert since late 1918, containing women's clothing, bedding, photographs, and kitchenware. 15. When confronted in Regina in November 1919 and threatened with a murder charge, Wilson first claimed Mary had walked away after a quarrel at the Saskatoon train station, then attempted suicide overnight in the guardhouse by slashing his throat with a small pen knife, requiring multiple stitches at Regina General Hospital. 16. In a December 1919 statement, Wilson admitted to shooting Mary but claimed the shotgun accidentally discharged as he was re-entering his car; the autopsy found powder burns on Mary's nose, indicating the shotgun was pressed close to her face when fired. 17. The episode is documentary in tone, relying heavily on primary sources — police memos, letters, newspaper headlines, and Wilson's own statements — with minimal editorializing from the host. 18. The December 1919 discovery of Mary's remains in a frozen culvert north of Saskatoon, with police chopping three feet of frozen earth with axes and crowbars, is narrated with deliberate understatement that heightens the impact. 19. True crime listeners interested in archival research, WWI-era Canadian legal history, and cases driven by family persistence rather than police initiative will find this compelling. 20. Listeners who prefer cases without extended period context or two-part formats that require prior episode knowledge may find this format difficult to follow.

As heard by us

A patient Mountie scandal story built from records, reports, and a slow tightening case.

Canadian True Crime tracks Sergeant John Wilson as his official role in the Royal Northwest Mounted Police starts to collide with a private life built on deception.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A Mountie scandal built from paper trails, public image, and a marriage that didn't add up.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on