Canadian True Crime · Kristi Lee | Canadian True Crime

Colin Thatcher and the murder of JoAnn Wilson [3]

March 30, 2026·1 hr 22 min·7 clips
Colin Thatcher told his friend the only solution for his ex-wife was to hire someone to kill her.
Where we left off, it was 1984. Colin Thatcher was facing trial for the murder of his ex-wife, Joanne Wilson, and the Crown had already put a lot in front of the jury. They had heard about statements Thatcher allegedly made to Gary Anderson and Charles Wilde, plus remarks from his Palm Springs girlfriend, Lynn Mandel. Then the recorded call with Gary moved to the front of the case. Gary had talked about cleaning the nightclub, the 1974 Mercury, and getting rid of a black jacket, sunglasses, and a tuft of hair that seemed to come from a wig. Thatcher had answered with one word. On the stand, he said that answer was about regular clothing: a top coat, scarf, and gloves left in the car. The $500 payment got its own explanation too. Thatcher said he gave Gary money because Gary had car trouble and because he did not especially want to see him again. Other parts of the call needed the same kind of cleanup. When the two men discussed not being seen together, Thatcher tried to make it sound far less incriminating than the Crown's version. The host keeps the focus on the courtroom record, so the denials and explanations have to sit beside what the jury already heard. Thatcher seemed determined to explain the call himself. The Crown was not buying it. Its prosecutor said he had taken deny, deny, deny to brand new heights. The episode sits in that uneasy space, where every phrase starts to matter and a murder trial turns on what a jury believes a conversation really meant.

As heard by us

A courtroom reckoning built from recordings, testimony, and stubborn denial.

Colin Thatcher and the murder of Joanne Wilson play out here as a courtroom story about proof, denial, and the uneasy work of sorting one from the other.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want the courtroom words that made this murder trial hard to shake.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on