Canadian True Crime · Kristi Lee | Canadian True Crime

Colin Thatcher and the murder of JoAnn Wilson [2]

March 29, 2026·1 hr 16 min·6 clips
Colin Thatcher confessed to his girlfriend, 'I have to admit it is a strange feeling to have blown your wife away.'
1. Canadian True Crime Part 2 establishes how Colin Thatcher planned Joanne Wilson's murder through a network of associates over more than a year before the January 1983 killing. 2. Host Amy Lloyd narrates; key new witnesses introduced are Gary Anderson, associate and accomplice, and Lynn Mendel, Colin's former girlfriend who heard his confessions directly. 3. The episode's central question shifts from 'who did it' to 'how do investigators build an airtight case against a sitting politician who is careful and wealthy?' 4. Colin Thatcher is named Saskatchewan Minister of Energy and Mines by Premier Grant Devine in mid-1982, but is suddenly 'resigned' by Devine in January 1983 — just five days before Joanne's murder — with the premier citing 'family responsibilities' without elaboration. 5. In October 1982, five months before Joanne's murder, Colin holds an abandoned farm meeting with Gary Anderson, gives him a .357 Magnum revolver, and asks him to have a silencer made; the homemade silencers all fail to muffle the gunshot and are discarded. 6. On the morning of January 21, 1983 — the day of the murder — Gary Anderson parks a brown 1974 Mercury V8 one block from Colin's Moose Jaw home; Colin arrives wearing a black ski jacket, blue jeans, and sunglasses, takes the Magnum revolver, and tells Gary to listen to news reports and clean the car if anything happens to Joanne. 7. Colin's stated alibi places him at his ranch and then home in Moose Jaw for a 6pm dinner, but Joanne is seen pulling into her Regina garage a few minutes before 6pm, and Regina is 70 kilometres — approximately a 45-minute drive — from Moose Jaw. 8. Neighbours report a dark blue car with a man sitting unnaturally still and wearing tight rubber gloves parked near the Wilson home in the days before the murder; the vehicle is later traced to a 1981 Oldsmobile Colin checked out of the government's central vehicle agency on January 10. 9. The day after Joanne's murder, Colin drives to Regina to ask his lawyer Anthony Merchant how to obtain custody of nine-year-old Stephanie, then proceeds to a neighbour's house where the child is playing and forces his way in, physically prying Stephanie from the caretaker's arms while she screams 'Please Daddy, let me go.' 10. Police recover Stephanie from Colin's Moose Jaw home within hours; Colin and Merchant are both charged with abduction, though the charges against Colin are eventually dropped and Merchant pleads guilty to mischief with an absolute discharge. 11. Colin immediately applies to defer his upcoming $90,000 property settlement installment under a death clause in the settlement agreement — a clause that stated if Joanne were to die, the next payment could be deferred a year. 12. Gary Anderson comes forward after investigators link him to a rental car used in the first shooting of Joanne in May 1981; he negotiates full immunity in exchange for his testimony, revealing all the planning meetings, the silencer request, and Colin's multiple failed attempts to hire a hitman before deciding to act himself. 13. Gary tells police that Colin had been stalking Joanne's house for about a week before the murder and told him at their final meeting that he 'did not get her' the night before — the January 21st attempt succeeded where the previous night had failed. 14. In May 1984, eighteen months after the murder, police wire Gary Anderson with a recording device and a bulletproof vest for a final abandoned-farm meeting with Colin, who tells Gary investigators have 'zero else' to connect them and to 'deny, deny, deny' if approached. 15. As the men part, Gary says 'I'm glad you got her' and Colin replies 'Okay'; police subsequently find a green plastic bag at a pre-arranged location containing a $500 envelope, proving Colin paid Gary after the murder. 16. Lynn Mendel, Colin's girlfriend in Palm Springs who was 12 years his junior, breaks her silence 18 months after the murder, explaining she initially lied to police because she feared for her life; now divorced from Colin, she is ready to testify. 17. Lynn tells investigators Colin described the first May 1981 shooting in detail: he wore a wig and false beard, fired a high-powered rifle through triple-glazed glass, and told her with a laugh 'I didn't gauge the thickness of the glass, so the bullet obviously deflected because I only got her in the shoulder.' 18. Lynn also tells police that Colin smuggled the .357 Magnum revolver from Palm Springs to Canada by wrapping it in newspaper and packing it in a Barbie doll shower gift box so he would not have to declare it at customs. 19. Listeners who follow political scandal and domestic violence cases with detailed investigative evidence and multiple witnesses will find this the most forensically gripping instalment of the three-part series. 20. Those who find accounts of prolonged domestic abuse, child abduction, and cold-blooded planning deeply distressing may want to approach this episode with caution.

As heard by us

A methodical true-crime account built on logistics, testimony, and witness cooperation.

The episode stays close to the murder of JoAnn Wilson and the paper trail around it: the rust-colored car leaving the scene, the rental contract tied to Gary Anderson, and the hidden-key arrangement connected to Colin Thatcher's home in Moose Jaw.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a murder case that unfolds through evidence and testimony, not theatrics.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on