Camthropod · Cambridge Anthropology

Episode 29: The 'Political' in Northern Irish Protestant Marching Bands, by Sean French.

·28 min·1 clip
Being spat at and hit with petrol bombs can make marching feel more meaningful.
1. Camthropod episode 29, “The ‘Political’ in Northern Irish Protestant Marching Bands,” follows Sean French’s fieldwork on Protestant marching bands in Derry, Northern Ireland. 2. Sean French is both the speaker and the researcher, and he says he spent 14 months in Derry after first learning the flute with two ten-year-old beginners. 3. The episode asks how marching-band sound, especially Blood & Thunder drumming, becomes a form of political voice in post-conflict Derry. 4. French describes Blood & Thunder as a style with “particularly loud, pounding drums,” and a band member says the style combines “the best” of Maltry and pipe drumming. 5. A rural march scene shows a Protestant organizer speaking through a microphone, giving jewels for “60 years of service,” and ending with the British national anthem. 6. French says some Protestants in Derry feel they have made unfair concessions in the peace process and now experience themselves as a marginalized minority. 7. A band member argues that being called “thugs,” “bigots,” and “sectarian” silences Protestants who want to speak in the city. 8. French contrasts noisy bonfires on 11 July and 11 August with an indoor band competition where a judge listened from a hidden booth. 9. He links those contrasts to older Victorian ideas of martial self-discipline and to the British promotion of marching band music in working-class communities and colonies. 10. French also describes how some people in Derry see Blood & Thunder bands as connected to “street cred,” paramilitaries, and rebellious youth. 11. One flute player says the “silver flute is a posh instrument,” which shows how class and sound shape who feels at home in the band scene. 12. A school flute teacher says young people playing flutes and drums are often treated as “thugs,” while fiddle and uileann pipe players are called musicians. 13. Protestant community workers try to compare marching-band players with Irish traditional musicians, saying the difference is one of perception rather than musical worth. 14. French records both excitement and defiance as affects of marching, including a member who says it is a “thrill” to walk toward people who hate them and a response to petrol bombs, bricks, spit, and urine. 15. He also notes that some members keep Catholic friends, Catholic girlfriends, and Catholic workmates while still saying things like “fuck all Athenians” in band settings. 16. Another example of contradiction comes from young Protestants who sometimes shout “up the ra” for fun, even while the IRA is treated as an enemy and a former band member was assassinated in the 1990s. 17. The episode is interview-led but heavily ethnographic, mixing French’s fieldnotes, quoted speakers, and descriptive scenes from marches, practices, and bonfires. 18. Its tone stays analytical and careful, with close attention to sound, voice, and the changing meanings of political speech acts. 19. Listeners interested in Irish politics, ethnomusicology, and Protestant identity in Derry. 20. Listeners wanting a light, fast, or purely musical episode.

As heard by us

A careful study of how politics can be carried by sound, discipline, and belonging.

Camthropod follows Sean French's 2021 fieldwork with two Protestant marching bands in Derry and uses it to look at identity, noise, and public space.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Listen if you want a fieldwork story about Northern Irish Protestant marching bands and the politics of sound in Derry.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on