Caliphate · The New York Times

Chapter Two: Recruitment

April 26, 2018·33 min·1 clip

A journalist explains why ISIS recruits are more recognizable — and more frightening — than monsters like Omar Mateen.

A warning comes first. Before the recruitment story starts, the feed says Abu Huzaifa al-Qanadi was later identified as Shairoz Chowdhury and charged in Canada with perpetrating a hoax. The Times went back through the reporting and found a history of misrepresentations, with no corroboration that Chowdhury committed the atrocities he described in the original Caliphate podcast. That does not make the recruitment question go away. The cold open points to ISIS still drawing people in: Americans believed to be fighting for ISIS in the Middle East, Canadians identified as fighting in Syria and Iraq, Europeans connected to the group, and young girls believed to be heading toward it. Then the episode gets into influence. It follows al-Laki from American-born preacher and interfaith participant to al-Qaeda's leading propagandist in Yemen. The turn is handled carefully. The account connects it to the Iraq War, his own rejection of life in the United States, and his claim that jihad against America had become binding. His death changes the pull of the story. After a 2011 strike, al-Laki becomes a leader and, for English-speaking sympathizers, an icon killed by American power. The internet keeps him present. The guest describes his words, thoughts, and videos as something that keeps working on people trying to turn grievance into ideology. Then the focus tightens. Huzaifa talks about lying to his parents, feeling he had never made them proud, and deciding Canada had nothing for him. The fantasy gives him cover. He imagines fighting for people, dying as a martyr, and turning failure at home into sacrifice abroad. The reporting keeps pressure on the claim. It gives him room to explain the emotional logic of recruitment while the frame keeps reminding the listener that his bigger story later fell apart. That tension is the point. Recruitment comes through as propaganda, grievance, shame, status hunger, and a story someone repeats until it starts to feel like destiny.

As heard by us

A grave look at how ideology and internet messaging can pull someone toward violence.

This chapter follows the mechanics of ISIS radicalization through the post-Iraq War turn, Anwar al-Awlaki's lectures, and the private disappointment that can make violence feel like purpose. It is strongest when it lets the taped voices carry the weight.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a close look at how a radicalization story gets built, challenged, and re-examined, this chapter stays on the nerve.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Caliphate