Bropostles · Ethan and Patrick

Ep. 45 - Is Hating your Parish a good idea? - Saint Kolbe Studios

April 8, 2026·1 hr 23 min·5 clips
Pat and Abby discuss how 2016 shattered the unwritten rule that Catholic creators shouldn't talk about politics.
Pat and Abby show up to talk internet Catholicism. The host leans into the last decade, and the conversation keeps returning to 2016, 2020, and 2024 as the moments when things changed in major ways. Politics arrives quickly. One guest says there used to be an unwritten rule that Catholic celebrities and content creators did not talk about politics, then points to 2020 as the moment that line broke. Parish life takes over from there. The discussion turns to territorial parishes, personal parishes, and a Pittsburgh example that names an ICKSP parish for traditional Latin Catholics and St. Benedict for black Catholics. That is where the real tension sits. The conversation keeps asking who a priest is actually trying to feed when he narrows his focus to one loud group instead of the whole flock. Gladys enters the mix. A joke about starting Latin chants leads to the familiar email panic about returning to the pre-Vatican II church where women were hated. The book comes in from the side. Save Your Parish is presented as a way to deal with opposition, and the conversation treats that as a practical answer to parish leaders who prefer to dodge friction. The closing stretch mentions an article in First Things, coverage in Crisis Magazine, and the fact that everyone got mad, which the speaker treats as useful publicity. There is also a sales link. SaveYourParish.com gets a direct plug, along with the note that the book hit number one on Amazon for Catholicism. The tone stays loose. It moves from internet culture to parish logistics to book marketing without pretending those are separate worlds, because for this show they are usually the same mess in different clothes. The last note is practical. The whole conversation is built for listeners who care about parish life enough to argue about it and to laugh when the emails start.

As heard by us

Internet Catholicism, parish boundaries, and the emails from Gladys all land in one clear argument.

Pat and Abby trace internet Catholicism from 2016 through 2026, with 2020 and 2024 framed as moments when people say more out loud. The conversation stays tied to parish life, moving between territorial parishes, destination parishes, and personal parishes while circling back to…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If parish politics and internet Catholicism share a bloodstream, this is your episode.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on