Boston Blackie Radio · Jack Boyle

Boston Blackie - Mutiny Lead To Murder Aboard The Swan

·25 min·2 clips
The phony cabin boy confesses he murdered the real Jimmy Adams, the passenger, and the first mate to assume his identity.
The Swan is in fog. Captain Harlan tells Peterson that the weather is not his real worry, because he has a bad feeling the ship is headed for something worse. Peterson agrees. He says the crew is unhappy, then spells out the mutiny plan: reroute the vessel, split the cargo, and dress the whole mess up as business. Harlan keeps his dry edge. He answers Peterson and then Crandall with the same polite contempt, even as the room fills with threats, half-jokes, and a case that already seems to be drifting toward the deck. Crandall does not wait around. He says there was an attempted mutiny, says he heard about the killing from one of the crew, and gives Blackie five minutes to get off the ship or be arrested for loitering, or something close enough to that. Blackie stays. He tells Crandall he will spend those five minutes solving the case, while Rollins is told to keep him in sight and see that he goes ashore right away. The rope ladder becomes the next problem. Crandall takes the officers' and crew's fingerprints up to headquarters, complains about the ladder's safety, and then Blackie suddenly goes overboard while everyone on deck scrambles and shouts. Nobody stays calm. Miss Wesley and the others work to haul him back aboard, Blackie keeps acting unfazed, and the inspector just barely avoids turning a routine departure into a disaster. The fall mattered. Crandall realizes one rung in the ladder was cut, not broken, and Blackie starts treating that as the kind of detail that points straight at someone trying to steer the investigation off course. Jimmy Adams slips. Once Blackie mentions he has a rough idea who killed Crandall, the phony Jimmy Adams vanishes, cuts the ladder rung in hopes of making Blackie drop into the water, and later gives himself away by heading for Blackie's apartment. That leaves Blackie smiling. He figures Jimmy would have stayed aboard and made a fool of him if he had not jumped ship, which is about as close as this story gets to a victory lap.

As heard by us

A lean Swan mystery keeps tightening around a killing, mutiny talk, and sharp dialogue.

The Swan story keeps its setup tight: fog, mutiny talk, a captain who holds his nerve, and a crew already bargaining over cargo and loyalty. The killing gives the mystery its first hard edge, and the threat of a wider breakdown on board keeps the pressure up from the start.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Play it if you want a mutiny mystery that starts sour and keeps getting stranger fast.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on