Blank Check with Griffin & David · Blank Check Productions

The Man Who Wasn't There with Jordan Hoffman

September 7, 2025·2 hr 35 min·5 clips

From 1996 to 2003, Billy Bob Thornton might have been Hollywood's best working actor—what changed?

Guest Jordan Hoffman, a film critic, joins the Blank Check hosts to discuss the Coen Brothers' ninth film, The Man Who Wasn't There, released in 2001. The episode opens with a debate about Billy Bob Thornton's career peak from roughly 1996 to 2003, arguing he had a legitimate claim to being Hollywood's best working actor during that stretch despite now being primarily known as a television star on Landman and a public eccentric. The production history traces back to the Coens finding vintage 1940s barbershop haircut posters and becoming interested in the man who cut all those heads of hair. They initially considered adapting James M. Cain's Mildred Pierce but instead wrote an original story about a barber. The working title was The Barber. They had two scripts ready simultaneously, this one and O Brother Where Art Thou, and made O Brother first when George Clooney became available. The film was shot in color by Roger Deakins and converted to black and white in post-production, partly because black-and-white film stock was limited and partly because Deakins found existing black-and-white stocks too grainy and documentary-feeling. The Coens note that while audiences assumed they were doing a noir pastiche, their actual visual references were low-budget 1950s B-movie science fiction films, which produced different gray tones and a less shadowy look than classic noir. The hosts discuss the film's release timing. It won best director at Cannes in May 2001, tied with David Lynch for Mulholland Drive. But its theatrical release came five to six weeks after September 11, and the hosts argue the somber, downbeat tone made it nearly impossible for audiences to connect with it. It became the Coens' lowest-grossing film since The Hudsucker Proxy. Thornton's performance is analyzed at length. The Coens describe him as understanding the required stillness, and Thornton himself reportedly would pull back even further during takes, asking if a slight smile was too much. The hosts note he may have fewer than twenty lines of spoken dialogue despite narrating the entire film. The discussion touches on how Thornton functions as an unconventional leading man in the Humphrey Bogart mold, magnetic and compelling despite being visually odd. The episode covers the supporting cast. Frances McDormand plays the wife in her first Coen collaboration since Fargo. James Gandolfini appears in an early post-Sopranos film role. Tony Shalhoub delivers what the hosts consider his best Coen performance, essentially playing a more grounded version of his Barton Fink character. The hosts note that the anticipated supporting actor and actress Oscar campaigns for Gandolfini and McDormand did not materialize because neither role had the expected screen time. Bill Murray was originally considered for the lead, and the hosts connect this to Bad Santa, which was also conceived as a Murray vehicle before Thornton stepped in late. The Coens met Thornton at a Super Bowl party through a mutual friend. Jordan Hoffman shares a story about presenting a Randy Newman lifetime achievement award at the New York Film Critics Circle dinner, making jokes in front of Scorsese, De Niro, Spike Lee, Brad Pitt, and Quentin Tarantino, with the front row remaining stone-faced throughout. The discussion addresses the film's multiple interpretations, including a reading of Ed Crane as a closeted gay man. The hosts examine the James M. Cain narrative structure where a single bad decision cascades into worsening consequences. Thornton's well-documented real-life phobias are discussed, including his fear of antiques and obsessive-compulsive rituals on set that the Coens found amusing rather than annoying.

As heard by us

A fast, funny case for Billy Bob Thornton as a singular screen presence.

Blank Check treats Billy Bob Thornton as the center of gravity here, and that choice pays off. The episode keeps circling the same useful question: how did he go from that 1996-to-2003-or-4 stretch into the public-kook version of Billy Bob Thornton that most people know now?

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

Press play for a Billy Bob Thornton defense that turns into a sprawling, joke-heavy movie hang.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Blank Check with Griffin & David