Better Physician Life: How to Get Unstuck in Your Medical Career · Doctor Podcast Network, Physician Coach, Michael Hersh MD

Physician Feedback: How to Take Criticism and Keep Growing | Ep26

January 26, 2026·19 min·1 clip
Why does feedback feel like a spotlight on your flaws, and how can that defensiveness be the start of growth?
Dr. Michael Hirsch begins with a familiar setup: someone says they want to give feedback, and the body reacts before the mind has time to catch up. He names the jolt that follows and shows how quickly physicians can slip into defense mode. That reaction, he says, is not a character flaw. It is training. Doctors are used to fixing problems fast, and that habit can make feedback feel like something to push away instead of something to examine. He makes the first shift simple and practical. Listen before you respond. Let the feedback land before deciding what it means. If the inner voice starts insisting it is not true or that they do not get it, he says to pause anyway. The goal is not instant agreement. The goal is to avoid missing something useful because the reflex to protect yourself showed up too early. After that pause, he moves into reflection. Ask what part of the feedback might be true. Ask what the actual data is. He keeps the question grounded so it does not turn into self-attack. The point is not, am I terrible. The point is, is there something I can take from this. Then he draws a line that matters. Not every piece of feedback deserves to be carried. Some of it is inaccurate. Some of it is unfair. Some of it is not yours to keep. That is why he describes feedback as an offering rather than a command. You can take what helps and leave the rest. He pushes the idea further by contrasting teachability with becoming a sponge. Being open does not mean absorbing everything. It means staying curious enough to sort signal from noise. He also gives the listener a clear mental model. Treat feedback like lab data. You do not get mad at a lab value. You interpret it and decide what to do next. That comparison turns criticism into something readable instead of something personal. Over time, he says, the reflex changes. The old jolt may still show up, but you learn to recognize it as old wiring. You notice it. You pause. You move on. He ends where the episode has been headed all along: growth is usually not dramatic, and it does not require perfection. It requires the willingness to keep learning. The closing message stays steady rather than grand. Feedback can hurt, but it can also help you choose better. Keep the useful part. Let the rest go. That is how physicians keep growing without losing themselves in the process.

As heard by us

A calm, practical reset for the reflex to defend yourself.

The episode frames criticism as something to sort, not something to absorb whole. It walks through a simple sequence: pause, listen before answering, ask what might be true, and keep only what is useful.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If criticism makes you brace, this gives you a cleaner way to pause, listen, and take what is useful.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on