Best Friends with Nicole Byer and Sasheer Zamata · Headgum

Nicole’s Ice Cream Escapades

March 4, 2026·1 hr 12 min·2 clips
Nicole explains how a Facebook Marketplace Ninja Creamy became nightly ice cream after a 30-minute drive to East Pasadena.
1. Best Friends with Nicole Byer and Sasheer Zamata centers on Nicole’s Ninja Creamy, a “special investigation unit,” and a possible Foster’s Freeze run. 2. Nicole Byer and Sasheer Zamata host the show, with Nicole driving most of the ice cream and home-maintenance stories and Sasheer reacting to each one. 3. The episode’s hook is that Nicole can make almost any frozen dessert at home, but still treats soft serve like an outing. 4. Nicole explains that the Ninja Creamy needs a base frozen for “16 to 24 hours or more,” then “creamifies” it in a few minutes. 5. She describes a used machine bought on Facebook Marketplace in East Pasadena for “$50 less,” after previously returning a new one because the instructions felt overwhelming. 6. Nicole lists several mixes: Strawberry Milk Nesquik, vanilla with peanut butter and Reese’s, cocoa powder pudding, and a Diet Dr Pepper base. 7. Sasheer pushes on the texture problem when the Reese’s become “a little too smooth,” and they compare that to wanting chunks in ice cream. 8. The conversation branches into a manual juicer, kumquats, and a palmolive from a community garden, with Nicole saying Facebook Marketplace “got the stuff.” 9. Later, Nicole recounts a water bill that “more than doubled,” a plumber visit, LADWP showing up without a time window, and being told to contact a “special investigation unit.” 10. People who like loose, joke-heavy conversations about food, bodies, and everyday logistics.
Listen to the show on