Behind the Headlines Podcast · WKNO/The Daily Memphian

1629: Outgoing Public Defender Phyllis Aluko

·32 min·2 clips

Aluko says the real question is whether the system locks up an innocent person or lets someone re-offend.

1. Behind the Headlines Podcast focuses on retiring Shelby County Chief Public Defender Phyllis Aluko and her 32 years in the office. 2. Host Eric Barnes and Daily Memphian reporter Bill Dries speak with Aluko because she has led the office for about seven years and has rarely done interviews. 3. The episode asks what has changed most in Shelby County public defense and how those changes affect due process. 4. Aluko says the office has grown significantly and now averages about 81 to 83 attorneys. 5. She explains the shift from horizontal representation to vertical representation, where one lawyer follows a case from General Sessions Court through criminal court. 6. She says the office now handles more than 20,000 cases a year, with some work moving into treatment courts from private attorneys. 7. Aluko says her major cases team handles murder-first-degree matters vertically through disposition. 8. She rejects the TV image of a public defender who walks into court at the last minute with a stack of files. 9. She says her lawyers are trained to triage cases quickly while still slowing the system down when a client's case needs more time. 10. She describes the system as wanting to operate like an assembly line and says, "We're not into assembly line justice." 11. Aluko says co-defendant cases create conflict problems because the office can only represent one co-defendant in her view. 12. She warns that one conflict can force the office off an entire case and strain the county's already limited pool of criminal defense lawyers. 13. She says the Memphis Safe Task Force has produced a 50% to 100% increase in appointments in some divisions. 14. She calls the Safe Task Force a generational event and compares its impact with COVID, which also changed the office's work. 15. Aluko says cameras and video footage have changed defense work because lawyers now have to review and store large amounts of digital evidence. 16. She says video sometimes helps the defense and sometimes helps lawyers reset a client's expectations about the case. 17. Aluko says treatment courts fit better with restitution and rehabilitation than a system focused mainly on retribution. 18. She says the jail's conditions and pretrial detention pressures can push people to plead out while in custody. 19. The episode feels like a direct interview with Barnes and Dries pressing practical questions while Aluko answers in a measured, policy-focused style. 20. People interested in Memphis courts, public defense, and criminal justice reform would get the most from this episode; listeners wanting celebrity talk or crime storytelling probably would not.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Behind the Headlines Podcast