Behind the Balance Sheet · Stephen Clapham's Podcast on Value Investing | Stockmarket Analysis | Equities

#41 The Composer - Anthony Bolton on 28 Years of 19.5% Returns, Mistakes & Staying Humble

·1 hr 21 min·2 clips

The exact process Bolton used in 4,000+ company meetings to build winning positions

This episode features an interview with legendary investor Anthony Bolton, conducted live at Edinburgh's Library of Mistakes. Bolton achieved a remarkable 19.5% annual return over 28 years managing the Fidelity Special Situations Fund, outperforming his benchmark by six percentage points. Host Stephen Clapham explores the principles behind this exceptional track record. Bolton argues that avoiding major mistakes, not just picking winners, is the key differentiator between good and average fund managers. He emphasizes the critical importance of being unemotional, flexible, and open to being wrong, stating that arrogance is detrimental to investment success. His contrarian philosophy led him to seek opportunity in unpopular areas and sell when investments became too popular. Bolton relied heavily on in-person company meetings, keeping detailed handwritten notes to track management consistency over time. He built and sold positions incrementally, scaling them as his conviction grew or as the risk-reward profile changed. A surprising insight is Bolton's use of technical analysis, specifically stock charts, to gauge whether he was "early or late" on an idea, a practice some fundamental investors dismiss. He also placed significant value on analyzing shareholder registers to see which other investors owned a stock. Bolton reveals that during bull markets, his portfolio typically held more stocks, while bear markets were for pruning and concentrating on his highest-conviction ideas. He shares that his only performance discussion with Fidelity's Ned Johnson came after three consecutive years of underperformance in the early 1990s. Bolton describes a "prospectus test" used in analyst recruitment, where candidates were given company information and asked to present a buy or sell case, assessing their thought process and communication. He valued analysts who presented their genuine views, not what they thought he wanted to hear. The episode closes with an anecdote about George Soros once trying to recruit him, leaving a lunch meeting with the remark that "you Brits are not interested enough in money." The tone is conversational and educational, with a deep respect for the guest's experience and a focus on extracting timeless investment wisdom. Clapham acts as an informed guide, prompting Bolton to elaborate on specific practices from his career. Fundamental stock pickers and contrarian investors will love this episode for its detailed, first-hand account of building a stellar long-term record. Listeners seeking discussions on modern market dynamics or specific stock tips might want to skip it.

As heard by us

A calm look at how temperament, portfolio construction, and process sit underneath investing success.

Anthony Bolton comes across less as a legend than as a useful test case for judgment and fit. The episode works best when it keeps returning to the practical question of what separates a capable analyst from a fund manager: temperament, portfolio construction, and the discipline…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to hear how an investor separates luck, skill, and temperament.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Behind the Balance Sheet