Beer and Conversation with Pigweed and Crowhill

574: Why are you gay? The Milo Yiannopoulos interview with Tucker Carlson

·37 min·3 clips

Pigweed and Crowhill dissect why the viral Ugandan interview question 'Why are you gay?' became so hilarious to Western audiences.

The episode begins with the hosts introducing the beer review, a black lager called Awkward Silence from Flying Dog. They quickly transition to discussing the viral Ugandan interview where a journalist asks 'Why are you gay?' and analyze why it became so hilarious in Western contexts. The hosts argue that this humor stems from societal conditioning since the 1980s, where the 'born this way' narrative was strategically adopted to frame homosexuality as a civil rights issue. They reference Milo Yiannopoulos's interview with Tucker Carlson, noting Milo's background as a former Breitbart editor and flamboyant gay conservative. The discussion covers Uganda's 'aggravated homosexuality' law, which includes penalties for acts like homosexual rape of children, and how Western funding cuts impacted the country. Milo's claim that homosexuality is a trauma response is detailed, with factors like absent fathers, overbearing mothers, or childhood rape cited as contributors. The hosts mention Milo's shift to being 'ex-gay' and celibate, contrasting it with debates over conversion therapy. They critique the gay community's alleged promiscuity and lack of monogamy, as per Milo's assertions. The episode also explores the historical shift in gay activism from anti-marriage stances to embracing marriage and adoption in the 1980s, referencing the book 'After the Ball'. The hosts discuss how assimilation has led to a loss of creativity in the gay community, turning it into 'enforcers' of orthodox thought. Milo's provocative statement about gay men being attracted to 'ugly, fat women' as a form of revenge on their mothers is mentioned. Throughout, the hosts emphasize they are not endorsing Milo's views but presenting them as a fascinating perspective from an 'expert' insider.

As heard by us

A beer-soaked argument that keeps asking why the joke landed.

Beer and Conversation with Pigweed and Crowhill starts with a black lager and then settles into the Milo-Tucker interview. The hosts circle a viral Ugandan clip and dig into why a blunt line can read as funny, then keep pressing on the assumptions underneath that response.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want beer, conversation, and an argument over a viral interview.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Beer and Conversation with Pigweed and Crowhill