Ep 7 - Rabbi Avi Kahan - Judaism and Finding God Through Debate of Law

·1 hr 29 min·5 clips

Orthodox Jews spend 10 hours a day screaming in debate to find God's truth through law.

This episode features host Josh Gold in conversation with Rabbi Avi Kahan, an Orthodox Jewish scholar and arbitrator who explores the relationship between divine law and human society. Rabbi Kahan explains that Orthodox Jews spend up to ten hours daily debating religious law, viewing this intense study as a path to understanding God. He describes a historical tension between secular and religious Zionists regarding the foundation of the State of Israel. Rabbi Kahan contrasts the divine inspiration behind religious law with the practical application of secular legal systems, referencing the American First Amendment as a secular framework. He cites the Talmudic accounts of the rival schools of Shammai and Hillel, which fiercely debated every topic yet intermarried and remained friends. The rabbi mentions Theodor Herzl's initial proposal to establish a Jewish homeland in Uganda before being convinced to choose Israel. He references Mark Twain's observation about the inexplicable survival of the Jewish people without a homeland for two thousand years. A surprising insight is Rabbi Kahan's interpretation that communal suffering, as promised to Abraham, ensures the Jewish people remember God. He argues that law itself is neutral, becoming an "elixir of life" or a "poison" depending on the purity of the person interpreting it. The rabbi claims the perfect divine law given to Moses exists, but humanity does not yet fully understand it. He presents a provocative Talmudic text suggesting God allowed a destined persecutor to live as an infant because divine punishment only follows actual deeds. Rabbi Kahan illustrates the passionate, confrontational style of Talmudic debate, where study partners may scream as if wanting to "destroy" each other but remain best friends. He notes a current political conflict in Israel where some Orthodox groups resist army service to prioritize full-time religious study. The conversation touches on modern legal dilemmas, using child support mandates and the "baby Hitler" thought experiment to contrast religious and secular moral reasoning. The tone is a relaxed, exploratory dialogue between a curious host and a knowledgeable guest, blending education with personal perspective. The style is conversational and philosophical, moving from abstract principles to specific historical and contemporary examples. Listeners interested in interfaith dialogue, legal philosophy, or the internal dynamics of Orthodox Judaism would find this episode compelling. Those seeking a strictly narrative or non-religious discussion of current events might find the theological focus less engaging.

As heard by us

Judaism is presented as a legal tradition of disciplined argument, moral self-checking, and practical judgment.

Rabbi Avi Kahn and Josh Gold present Judaism as a tradition shaped by law, argument, and disciplined study. The discussion treats the Talmud as a guide for learning, debating, and sorting custom from law, while also asking whether those who spend more time in that legal world…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want religion argued through real disputes, this one goes straight to the rule book.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Bad At My Religion