BackStory

Mystery, Murder, and Mayhem: A History of True Crime in America

May 29, 2020·1 hr 7 min·2 clips
Frances Glessner Lee turned meticulous miniatures into police training tools for investigating deaths without relying on intuition.
1. BackStory traces American true-crime history from Frances Glessner Lee's 1940s miniature crime scenes to Truman Capote's 1966 In Cold Blood. 2. Hosts Ed Ayers and Joanne Freeman guide interviews with author Rachel Monroe, lawyer Kara Robertson, and true-crime scholar Sarah Sliger. 3. The episode argues that true-crime stories reflect changing ideas about evidence, gender, media, and criminal justice, not only who committed a crime. 4. Monroe describes Lee's Nutshell Studies, where tiny clues and dead dolls trained police to question first impressions. 5. Lee funded Harvard's first U.S. department of legal medicine when many coroners investigated deaths without medical training. 6. Robertson recounts Andrew and Abby Borden's 1892 murders and Lizzie Borden's trial, where the jury acquitted her in 20 minutes. 7. Borden's case drew yellow journalism, gruesome courtroom exhibits, and a female audience journalists described as a “second jury.” 8. Sliger calls In Cold Blood a “why done it,” exploring the Clutter murders and the backgrounds of Perry Smith and Dick Hickock. 9. A scholar found nearly 5,000 differences between Capote's New Yorker text and book, while Kansas's insanity standard dated to the 1840s. 10. Listeners interested in American crime history, forensic science, and criminal justice.
Listen to the show on