Back to the Bins #697 – Batman: Year One

The episode begins with host Paul Spitaro introducing the panel, including Chris Eberle who requested the topic. Eberle opens by explaining why Batman: Year One is his favorite Batman story, citing the creative team of Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli and its mythic portrayal of Batman. He emphasizes the importance of Gotham as a character and Gordon's narration. Paul Spitaro counters that the story feels more like Commissioner Gordon Year One, a point the group largely agrees with, discussing Gordon's moral struggles and affair. Sean Whalen notes Batman's vulnerability and mistakes in his early vigilante attempts. The conversation shifts to David Mazzucchelli's artwork, with praise for his storytelling and noir aesthetic. Adam Murdo shares a quote from Mazzucchelli about the challenge of balancing realism with superhero genre absurdity. The panel discusses the noir influences, including film and radio dramas, and identifies Gregory Peck as a visual model for Bruce Wayne. They analyze specific scenes, like Batman's first combat and the finale where Gordon's son is kidnapped. Comparisons are made to other Batman media, including the Nolan films and the 2011 animated adaptation. The episode concludes with thoughts on the animated movie's faithfulness and limitations.

As heard by us

A thoughtful Batman: Year One discussion that stays grounded in character and continuity.

Back to the Bins visits Batman: Year One in a conversation that benefits from Paul Spitaro's long familiarity with the book and his admission that he had not read all four issues in one stretch until now.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A Batman: Year One chat that keeps circling Gordon, Essen, and the strain on one very inconvenient marriage.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify