Ave Maria in the Afternoon Segments

Critical Theory Destroys – Let’s Respond with Love

·22 min·2 clips
Marcus Peter introduces the seductive promise of critical theory to eradicate injustice by destroying hierarchies, posing the Christian challenge.
Marcus Peter frames critical theory as deeply rooted among modern political and social thinkers. He names the central Christian concern as the social sins of the past and the promise of ending injustice by tearing down hierarchies and structures of dependency. Michael Terrien joins the conversation to define the philosophy and explain its influence. He places socialism, Marxism, and communism inside a wider philosophical framework that also includes elements of radical feminism and radical ecology. That framework, he says, comes from nineteenth-century thinkers. Peter then returns to Terrien's two pieces for the What We Need Now Substack. The discussion asks why critical theory's language can sound almost Christian when it presents itself as compassion. Terrien grants that it notices places where people in social dependency are not receiving their due in the order of justice. He draws a firm line between that diagnosis and the remedies proposed. Those remedies, in his account, do violence to the natural law and the natural moral order established by God. The argument turns on a hard irony. A movement trying to wipe out injustice can become the very evil it says it wants to destroy. Terrien describes select elites appointing themselves to level the playing field for everyone else. He ties that authority to the violence required when resistance to giving the state that kind of power is treated as an obstacle. The conversation invokes tyrannical and autocratic regimes as the pattern that follows when this approach is attempted. Terrien calls the resulting social vision a parody of the kingdom of God. Its language may sound gospel-like. Its promised end, he argues, is chased through evil means. Peter closes by thanking Terrien and directing listeners to Preambula.org, where the organization and Wise Guys podcast can be found. He also points listeners to the two critical-theory pieces linked in the day's program and urges them to learn why Terrien and Peter believe critical theory should be opposed.

As heard by us

A pointed conversation on critical theory, coercive remedies, and the Christian meaning of love.

Marcus Peter's conversation with Michael Terrien looks at critical theory as a promise to end injustice by tearing down hierarchies and social structures of dependency.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want to understand critical theory before its promise to eradicate injustice starts rearranging your moral furniture.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →
Listen to the show on