Attaching to God: Neuroscience-informed Spiritual Formation · Geoff and Cyd Holsclaw

132 Is Joy Even More Central Than Love? (Replay for Thanksgiving)

·22 min·1 clip

Joy is the experience of being with someone who is glad to be with you.

1. Attaching to God: Neuroscience-informed Spiritual Formation centers Episode 132 on whether joy is even more central than love. 2. Jeff Holzclaw hosts as president and founder of the Center for Embodied Faith, visiting professor of theology at Western Theological Seminary, and longtime pastor. 3. Sid matters because she brings a neuroscience-informed definition of joy that draws on Jim Wilder, Carl Lehman, and attachment language. 4. The episode asks what joy is for if Christianity commands love, yet people live amid outrage, cynicism, oppression, and everyday difficulty. 5. Jeff introduces Juergen Moltmann’s essay Christianity, a religion of joy and his question about laughing while “new tears are being added every day.” 6. Moltmann’s contrast between Christian feasts and the cross becomes the theological frame for the whole discussion. 7. Sid says many people hear joy as “happy clappy,” childish, privileged, or a form of spiritual bypassing. 8. She names the social backdrop directly: global warming, a pandemic, violence, oppression, slavery, and political life. 9. Jeff adds an example from the Missio Alliance gathering in Chicago and Natasha Strunk Robinson’s account of growing up in the black church. 10. Robinson’s phrase “giving a joyful shout” appears as a counterexample to the idea that suffering and joy cannot coexist. 11. Sid defines joy as “the experience of being with someone who is glad to be with you.” 12. She links that definition to infants who are wanted, anticipated, and welcomed by caregivers, family, and friends. 13. The episode says repeated faces of gladness help build the part of the brain associated with joy and with a sense of self. 14. Sid distinguishes joy from simple happiness, saying a person can be happy alone when circumstances go well but not necessarily joyful without relational gladness. 15. Jeff and Sid then shift to “amplifying joy,” which they contrast with only minimizing infant distress like hunger, tiredness, or being startled. 16. Sid describes the research claim that positive affective states and positive social-emotional interactions build the brain more, not merely as much, as reducing distress. 17. Their examples include peekaboo, smiling, eye contact, baby games, and a Sunday scene in Chicago with a baby and an older couple across the pew. 18. The discussion stays conversational and reflective, with Jeff prompting transitions and Sid building a practical theology from neuroscience, worship, and family life. 19. People interested in attachment, spiritual formation, gratitude practices, and the role of joy in Christian life will likely find this useful. 20. Listeners looking for a tight Bible-study-only episode without neuroscience or parenting examples may skip it.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Attaching to God: Neuroscience-informed Spiritual Formation