Appalachian Murder, Mystery And Legend · Larry Bentley

Injustice Is Served

·31 min·3 clips

Leo Frank: a Jewish factory superintendent in 1913 Atlanta—guilty before the first question was asked

Larry Bentley starts by framing Appalachia as a place with beauty, hardship, and a long run of stories worth telling. He reminds the listener that the Appalachian Mountains are old, wide, and full of tragic and strange happenings. He also places himself inside that world as somebody born and raised there. The setup makes plain that this is an Appalachian telling, not a neutral office memo. He then opens season five with a sharp opinion about southern aristocrats. He says not all of them are power-hungry, and that many of them are among the nicest folks you’ll ever meet. The real trouble, in his view, comes from the ones who get into politics. From there the episode moves into a murder case with ugly social pressure around it. Bentley lingers on old funeral practice and explains the use of a custom carved marble slab in the mortuary, which helped cool the body and slow decomposition. That detail gives the story a grim, tactile feel. It also keeps the narration rooted in lived custom instead of polished true crime distance. Leo is then taken on what is basically a one-man tour of the crime scene. The detectives watch him closely while the damage is still visible on the floor, walls, ceiling, and even the light bulb. Bentley suggests that they are trying to read Leo as much as they are trying to gather evidence. After a long day of that pressure, they decide he probably is not the person they are looking for, at least for the moment. The story then lands on April 29th, the day of Mary’s funeral. By then the citizens of Atlanta are beyond fed up with not having an arrest. Bentley describes the crowd mood as the kind of anger that starts sniffing around for somebody to hang. He does not soften that part. He talks about lynching as illegal on paper, but useless against a mob in motion unless somebody stops it. That blunt judgment is the emotional center of the ending. The episode closes with the sense that justice is being pulled one way and public fury another. Bentley signs off in his usual neighborly way, asking listeners to rate, review, follow, and come back for more mountain-country storytelling.

As heard by us

A grim Appalachian murder story told with local color, pressure, and a blunt, steady voice.

This episode treats Appalachia as both a place and a memory, moving between the region's beauty, its hardship, and the murder case at the center of the story.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

A mountain murder story where a funeral, public anger, and a stalled investigation keep the pressure on.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Appalachian Murder, Mystery And Legend