Animation Addicts Podcast - Disney, Pixar, & Animated Movie Reviews & Interviews | Rotoscopers · Rotoscopers

Wicked: For Good - I Want a Blue Horse

·1 hr 2 min·4 clips

Morgan says Act One is "significantly stronger" than Act Two and that the sequel has an uphill battle.

1. Animation Addicts Podcast episode 358 covers Wicked: For Good, the sequel to the 2024 Wicked film and the second half of the Broadway story. 2. Morgan Stradling and Chelsea Robson host the review as the Animation Addicts regulars who saw the movie separately and then compared notes. 3. The episode asks whether Wicked Part Two can work when Act Two is already the weaker half of the stage musical. 4. Morgan says Act One of Wicked is "significantly stronger" than Act Two, and Chelsea agrees that the earlier half has the bigger songs and the more satisfying stopping point. 5. The hosts say the film keeps the cast, sets, choreography, and music from Part One, so viewers who liked Ariana Grande and Cynthia Erivo in the first movie will likely like them here too. 6. They also say the sequel has an uphill battle because the play's second act is shorter, more rushed, and harder to expand into a full movie. 7. Morgan says the film adds material to reach 137 minutes, but the added scenes do not solve the structural weakness of the story. 8. Chelsea says anyone who did not like Part One probably will not like Part Two, because the same production choices carry over. 9. Morgan praises Alice Brooks's cinematography in Glinda's closet sequence and points to the mirror work as a visual highlight. 10. He and Chelsea call out the new songs "No Place Like Home" and "The Girl in the Bubble" as slower and less memorable than the Broadway material. 11. Morgan says the two new songs sound like padding and do not have Stephen Schwartz's usual lyrical charm. 12. Chelsea says the song selection still preserves the major musical moments fans expect, including "Wonderful," "As Long as You're Mine," and "For Good." 13. Morgan says Jeff Goldblum works better as an actor than as a singer, while Michelle Yeoh's singing stands out to him as a weaker part of the film. 14. Chelsea says Cynthia Erivo is a phenomenal singer but gives an Elphaba performance that feels muted and melancholy. 15. Morgan says Ariana Grande makes Glinda her own, but he still reads the performance as "cosplaying Glinda" rather than fully inhabiting the character. 16. The hosts discuss Nessarose, Boq, the wheelchair casting choice, and the film's altered approach to the silver slippers and flying. 17. Morgan and Chelsea keep the tone conversational and reaction-based, with frequent comparisons to the Broadway version and a running back-and-forth about specific scenes. 18. The episode mixes theater knowledge, movie-review structure, and real-time audience reactions, including reactions to the movie's darker visual style and the PG-rated romantic material. 19. Best for Wicked fans comparing the film to the stage musical. 20. Skip if you want spoiler-free broad-family movie coverage.

As heard by us

Morgan Stradling and Chelsea Robson offer a grounded Wicked for Good discussion with sharp notes on songs, staging, and visuals.

Morgan Stradling and Chelsea Robson spend most of the conversation on Wicked for Good, and the best stretches are the ones that stay close to the work itself.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

If you want a lively Wicked: For Good take with strong song-and-set opinions.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Animation Addicts Podcast - Disney, Pixar, & Animated Movie Reviews & Interviews | Rotoscopers