Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts · Slate Podcasts

One Amendment Explains It All

December 13, 2025·1 hr 3 min·5 clips

Sherilyn Ifill reveals how the 14th Amendment created birthright citizenship and true democracy after the Civil War.

Dahlia Lithwick opens by acknowledging listener fatigue with the relentless pace of legal news before introducing Sherilyn Ifill, who has just published a Substack piece asking whether it is already too late to save American democracy. Ifill explains why the 14th Amendment, passed after the Civil War to enshrine birthright citizenship and racial equality, is the correct lens through which to understand the current administration’s actions: attacks on birthright citizenship, the marginalization of Somali-American congresswoman Ilhan Omar, the replacement of MLK Day with Trump’s birthday for free national park admission, and the broader project of reversing the “second founding” of the country. Ifill traces the anti-democratic thread from massive resistance to Brown v. Board of Education through Ronald Reagan’s Philadelphia, Mississippi campaign speech, arguing that what Trump has assembled is a continuation of that movement, now at its crudest and most explicit. She distinguishes between what has always been in America’s DNA and what was genuinely achieved by the civil rights, women’s, and LGBTQ rights movements—arguing that progress was real and that Trump’s project is specifically designed to wreck those achievements. Lithwick raises the Supreme Court, and Ifill responds with a sharp critique of the conservative majority’s willingness to invent facts and overrule trial court findings of record, which she sees as a structural corruption of the legal system beyond mere ideology. The conversation examines why the tech and business communities have failed to mount meaningful resistance and why journalists have been complicit in normalizing racial attacks by treating them as mere political spectacle. Ifill closes with a call to action: the window for democratic recovery requires demanding that those with the largest microphones tell the truth about the scope of what is happening. The tone is one of clear-eyed alarm rather than despair, grounded in Ifill’s 35 years as a civil rights litigator.

As heard by us

A sharp, urgent case for treating court talk as democracy talk.

Amicus turns court talk into a conversation about how democracy feels when the legal ground shifts. Dahlia Lithwick and Sherilyn Ifill keep the emphasis moving from doctrine to the costs of normalization, the fight over citizenship, and the point where institutions can no longer…

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

When you want the courts framed as democracy under pressure, this episode gives you that lens.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Amicus With Dahlia Lithwick | Law, justice, and the courts