American International Podcast · Jeff Markin and Cheryl Lightfoot

The First Deadly Sin

·55 min·1 clip

Key insight from segment 5

The show opens with a plain introduction to *The First Deadly Sin* and its place in the American International Podcast's run through human vices. Brian G. Hutton directs from Man Rubin's screenplay, based on Lauren Sanders' novel, and the hosts get that out of the way before the plot starts throwing elbows. Frank Sinatra plays Sergeant Edward X. Delaney, a man with two priorities and very little room to breathe. His wife matters. His job matters. Then two unknown killers put both in the crosshairs, and the movie turns from a clean hardboiled setup into a long, sour chase. The recap treats Delaney like a man who runs on instinct and has been doing it for a long time. That instinct takes him from the street into the kind of building that seems to judge your shoes. He starts asking about Daniel Blank, a private investigator who has supposedly been dating a client's 18-year-old daughter. George, the doorman, is only mildly helpful at first. Then Delaney starts spending the expense account, and George gets a little more talkative. He says Blank is tall, has been living there for about six months, and is due to move in a couple of weeks. George also drops one of those details that sounds too specific to be accidental: he has helped Blank load mountain-climbing equipment into a white 75 Porsche. The hosts let that sit for a moment, because it is exactly the kind of detail this movie expects people to accept without blinking. While George answers the switchboard, Delaney noses through the files, finds the key to Blank's apartment, and pockets an index card for good measure. George comes back, catches him, and takes the key away without any fuss. The meter is up on Delaney's twenty dollars. The building charges for everything. Delaney tries to buy more time and more access, because that is how this sort of investigation works. Money opens doors. So does stubbornness. So does being Frank Sinatra in a movie that wants to look hardboiled even when it is being a little ridiculous. The recap pauses just long enough to notice how transactional every conversation has become. George says no, then yes, then no again, and the whole exchange lands like a joke with bad manners. From there Delaney heads to Blank's workplace. He must have picked up the address from the card he stole, because the movie is not interested in dragging out every step. An attendant points him toward where Blank parks the Porsche, and the picture keeps its clues in plain sight. The hosts then cut to Blank himself, wearing a wig and riding an elevator with a crowd of commuters, which tells you exactly how seriously the movie wants to be taken. Not very. Or maybe just enough. The episode stays sharp whenever the film does. It moves from clue to clue, building to building, and small lie to small lie. Cheryl and Jeff do not stop to make a grand theory of it. They let the plot pile up detail instead. So the listener gets the props, the blocking, the shaky logic, and the little credit-line connections as they come up, which is where this show tends to work best. It does not try to polish the movie into something noble. It walks beside it and points at the strange parts. The hosts keep the tone simple, too. When something is ugly, they say so. When a line sounds absurd, they let it sound absurd. When a detail is funny because it is so specific, they do not squeeze it too hard. That gives the episode a companionable feel rather than an academic one, like two people walking you through a dusty crime picture while refusing to pretend the dust is glamorous. The result is a recap that cares more about motion than thesis, and more about observation than speechifying. By the end, the film has been framed as a grim procedural with old-star muscle, strange visual choices, and enough sleaze to earn its title. The show gives the listener a clear route through it, from the opening setup to the apartment key to the wig in the elevator. It is a solid fit for people who like their crime movies described in order and their commentary close to the plot. The next stop is the second deadly sin, which feels exactly like the sort of promise this show knows how to make.

As heard by us

A scene-by-scene Sinatra noir recap that keeps the investigation's odd little mechanics in view.

American International Podcast treats The First Deadly Sin as a careful, scene-by-scene walk through a late Sinatra crime film, following Sergeant Edward X. Delaney as he tries to protect his wife, keep his job, and stay ahead of two killers closing in.

Read the full review in PlayNext →

Why you'd press play

You want Sinatra noir with a side of sour, scene-by-scene housekeeping.

Read the full recommendation in PlayNext →

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from American International Podcast