Alternate Ending - Movie Review Podcast · Alternate Ending

Podcast Special: An Officer and a Spy

October 13, 2025·1 hr·4 clips

The ending line turns Dreyfus and Picard into a debate about duty, loyalty, and what the state actually rewards.

1. Alternate Ending focuses on An Officer and a Spy, the Roman Polanski film that won the Grand Jury Prize at the 2019 Venice Film Festival. 2. Tim Brayton hosts, Will Quaid returns as guest, and Will's recent essay in the International Journal of the Image gives him a direct link to the Dreyfus Affair material. 3. The episode asks why this film matters now, after its delayed U.S. release through Film Forum, one-off screenings, and Vitagraph. 4. Will says the French title references Emile Zola's press document, while the English title foregrounds Robert Harris, who wrote Conclave. 5. Tim notes that the 2019 Venice jury, led by Lucrezia Martel, placed the film second behind Joker. 6. The hosts discuss how the film resurfaced in the U.S. six years later, including a 2024 UK Jewish Film Festival screening and a Chicago Underground Film Festival booking. 7. Will argues that the release context invites readings about antisemitism, Zionist response, and the politics surrounding Israel and Palestine. 8. Tim pushes the discussion toward the film text itself and says the object on screen matters more than the surrounding controversy. 9. Will describes the Dreyfus Affair as a late-19th-century French case in which Alfred Dreyfus was convicted of treason and sent to Devil's Island. 10. Will explains that the case became inseparable from antisemitism once the army chose to keep Dreyfus imprisoned after discovering the real mole. 11. Will traces the affair's screen history from Georges Méliès's 1899 11-part serial to the 1937 The Life of Emile Zola. 12. He also names Richard Oswald's 1930s film, Jose Ferrer's I Accuse, and Ken Russell's HBO version as major precedents. 13. Tim says the earlier films often avoid saying the word Jewish, while this film makes the antisemitic logic explicit. 14. Will calls the film the definitive Dreyfus Affair version because it treats antisemitism as systemic cover for state failure. 15. Tim agrees that Roman Polanski's perspective matters because his films repeatedly frame historical suffering without sentimental closure. 16. The hosts point out that Georg Picquart, not Alfred Dreyfus, is the central character and that the story follows Picquart's investigation. 17. Tim says the film's pacing mirrors a real investigation: long stretches of little movement, then sudden accumulation of evidence. 18. They describe Alexandre Desplat's score and Paweł Edelman's images as part of a structure that slowly tightens around Picquart. 19. Tim says the film will suit viewers who want formal craft, historical adaptation, and Roman Polanski analysis. 20. The episode will likely skip for listeners who want a quick summary without Dreyfus Affair context or release-history debate.

Listen to the show on

Apple Podcasts Spotify

Play clips from this episode More from Alternate Ending - Movie Review Podcast